wi^-. 1^.
^^^'.'i-'^^rW:
if M
■^ W W mM
^'A^
.^^'
nFTAIIFnPi/.
Wl
'l/AOVO'
,A'i ' wviil >
uOPCAlIFORi^
-^y
55 ><
■'^/^ai\iwiit^>
^
' UU3I J » J J
'^/iaJAlNaJU^^ ""-cyAav^c
^4
fei
^INrtiVt^
mms/^
^OfCAllFOfti^ ^0FCAIIF(%
5 ^
■ J iiJ\'f JUl
,^MEUNIVERS/A
,?
"^^ilJDNVSOl
^
I1V3J0>'
Wl W
\
\^
\^
UNIVERS/4
f
AWMNIVERS//^.
^VIIBRARY.
35 , r -
.^
"^OAbvaaii-^v^
//Ja3AINfl3tt^
<r iitiii/rnr
''QUJIi7J JV)'
''«3UJl|VJiU'
^OFCA1IFO«>^ ^0FCA11F0%
%
.^^^l•llBRARY6{r
R^^ i
^OF CAllFO«j[^
5J^fl)NIVFRS/^ ^lOSANCfier^ ^vMllBRARYOr
.5MEUNIVRJ/A
ae =3 ^ — ^
vvlOSANCFlZ;r^
3 %a3AiNnjuv^
<riij3Nvsoi=<^ "^/saaAiNiuvw^ ^tfojiivojo^
^OFCAllF0ff>^
r-n
>&AavMivi^'^
ORIENT AND OCCIDENT
BY THE SAME AUTHOR
THE PROBLEM OF EXISTENCE:
Its Mystery, Struggle, and Comfort in the Light of Aryan Wisdom. Demy 8vo, cloth, los. 6d.
IMPRESSIONS OF A WANDERER.
Crown 8vo, cloth, 5s. net.
A STUDY IN IDEALS : Great Britain and India. Demy 8vo, cloth, los. 6d. net.
(Sec notice at the end, page 316.) LONDON: T. PISHER UNWIN
Orient and Occident
A COMPARATIVE STUDY
BY
MANMATH C. MALLIK
OF THE MIDDLE TEMPLE, BARRISTER-AT-LAVV,
FELLOW OF THE ZOOLOGICAL SOCIETY
OF LONDON,
AUTHOR OF " A STUDY IN IDEALS : GREAT BRITAIN AND INDIA," "THE PROBLEM OK EXISTENXE," ETC.
T. FISHER UNWIN LONDON: i ADELPHI TERRACE LEIPSIC : INSELSTRASSE 20
First published in 1913
{All rights reserved)
■^
^
^s- 5"
God hath made of one blood all nations of men for to dwell on all the face of the earth.
The Acts.
One altar alone shall be erected, humanity ; one principle alone, order ; one society alone, the world.
Gambetta.
Not though all men call, '^ Kneeling with void hands,
'vj Shall they see light fall
t^ Till it come for all
j^^ . Tribes of men and lands.
Swinburne.
Tach chhrutam yat kila jnaptyai sa jnaptih samata
yaya Tat samyam yatrddvaita drishtir jagati jayate.
Vasishtha.
r ' • • •
^ That IS worth hearmg which advances knowledge ;
that is knowledge which helps the growth of serenity;
that is serenity by which the vision of the unity of
T mankind is produced.
200025
PREFACE
Much of the matter contained in this volume was intended for incorporation in the author's " A Study in Ideals : Great Britain and India," published in the autumn of 1912 ; but to avoid making that volume too bulky such matter was left over to form the nucleus of a separate book, which is now placed before the reader, accom- panied by a chapter of Parallel Illustrations from the thoughts of the Sages of the East and of the West.
It is often asserted that Europe and Asia cannot understand each other— that Asia is a mystery to Europe, and must always remain ai mystery, and vice versa. The assertion is gener- ally made by persons whose nature or training or self-interest leads them not to wish the under- standing to take place. Similar assertions with reference to the relationship of different European countries were not long ago common, and indeed are still not unknown among extreme partisans of the old order. Between Europe and Asia science is bringing about a closer physical
X PREFACE
contact, which would, as in European countries, generate an understanding, had the law of nature not provided a counteracting influence in the shape of mutual distrust and suspicion caused by superficial and traditional differences. That attitude cannot continue much longer without imperilling the fabric upon which the future welfare of both West and East depends. A poUcy of courage and wisdom in authoritative quarters would speedily change the attitude ; but nowa- days authority, intellectual as well as political, seems too timid to lead opinion and too ready to succumb to popular prejudices. In the dearth of such courage and wisdom, it becomes the task of peacemakers and of believers in human brotherhood, hitherto few, but increasing in numbers and importance with growing enlight- enment, to endeavour to counteract and to minimize the influence of the opponents of human progress, so as to bring about a state of things in which the mutual understanding of East and West, however slow, may yet be steadily advanced. Chapter I treats of some similarities and dissimilarities in ideas and habits in the East and in the West. Chapter II deals with some notions of propriety in the Eastern and Western divisions of the Empire of Britain. Chapter III presents a parallelism in some of the thoughts of Eastern and Western sages.
PREFACE xi
Since the Royal visit and the Coronation Durbar, held under the brightest auspices and amid universal rejoicing, ushered in a new era of peaceful progress under the personal oversight of the Sovereign himself, the annals of Indian history have been sullied by an atrocious crime directed against the representative of the King, one of the best and most sympathetic rulers the country has ever had, on the day of his state entry into the new capital of British India. A con- dition of affairs in which a high officer of State in any part of the British dominions cannot, like the rulers of other civilized States, pass with- out risk of molestation along the streets of the capital of the country he governs is deplorable and intolerable. The police being inefficient and the authorities still blinding themselves by distrust and aloofness from the people, no clue has been discovered as to whether the crime was the act of a maniac, of an anarchist, of a Moslem fanatic, of a tool of some designing person in autliority, or of a secret society. Anarchism, homicidal mania, fanaticism — by whichever name it may be called— seems to have become as much a part of Indian conditions of life as it is of life in the West. The remedy for such diabolical acts is difficult to find : it is still more difficult to apply. Obviously enough, the efficiency of the police ought to be secured : they
xii PREFACE
should have ample powers with proper safeguards against abuse, and they should be patriotic and high-spirited enough to be anxious to remove from the service the stigma that even the authori- ties recognize that it now bears— the stigma of being permeated by traditions not only of corruption but of cruelty. But police reform, though patently necessary and urgent, is but a partial remedy. The knife must cut deeper.
The difference between the conditions in the East and in the West is glaringly displayed when a crime of this sort is committed, whether it be the act of a maddened brain or of a conspiracy embracing a group. In the East, it gladdens the hearts of reactionaries and of other enemies of human progress as affording an opportunity for the display of their importance and venom, and for preaching their doctrines for the enslavement of fellow-men. In India, Reaction cries out for more repression, as if harassment or even torture has ever in human history stopped crime. Such sage effusions only frighten and worry the innocent mass, while they scarcely reach the notice of those that are disposed to crime. If it is any use to expect anything sensible from the reactionary brain, it may be invited to con- tribute to the solution of the problem something wiser and more helpful than large talk of "our power," and homilies as to the duty of the people
PREFACE xiii
of India in general to help in the suppression and detection of crime. Both in the West and in the East " our power," of course, has to be asserted, sometimes openly but generally in quiet administrative measures, to keep all potential mischief-makers under control — to guard autho- rity from insult and assault, to protect wealth and its satellites from being robbed by needy muscles, to restrain privilege from tyrannizing over the helpless, and to silence incitements to hatred as well as to crime. In the East, however, there still exists an additional evil, which has wellnigh disappeared from the West. This evil was recently illustrated in the West at Versailles, where a woman was convicted for getting two hired assassins to murder her husband for 3,000 francs, and at Jersey City, New York, early in February, 1913, and in the East, in the trial of a European Army officer at Agra, who has just been convicted for having induced his Indian servants to murder his wife. It seems possible to get hold of hired ruffians— whose number a reactionary policy is bound to increase— to commit any crime for a few rupees. One can imagine how easy it would be for persons in authority to secure such miserable instruments for executing any nefarious designs. The police may be empowered to search every house, to arrest every suspect,
xiv PREFACE
to insult every citizen, but who shall effectively search the houses of policemen, of other officials, of non-official Europeans or of their tools, and who shall stop their making false accusations? Conditions in India are at present in a state of chaos. Order and light will come in time, but not without patience and perseverance under cool- headed and broad-minded statesmanship.
Critics may find fault with the manner of presentation of ideas in this volume and in its companion, with some of the ideas themselves, or with prolixity of statement. The criticism would be just if readers generally were familiar with the facts and with the bearings of the facts ; but, unfortunately, they cannot yet be said to have grasped the situation ; and even when facts are quite obvious, it is not always that people trace their influences on political and social life. This is not surprising when one reflects on the distance that still separates East from West, and on the imperious calls of more immediate interests and duties. In the circumstances, therefore, the author cannot but hold the opinion that the causes hindering the Empire of Britain from becoming the most potent instrument ever forged by Providence for the advancement of human welfare cannot be represented under too many aspects or too lucidly expressed. Should the author be deemed to fall short of the aim, he
PREFACE XV
will humbly hope that his critics, who must be equally interested, will make good his short- coming. The object is eminently worthy of the best minds among Britons.
This book, then, attempts to indicate the nature of some of the differences and of the agreements between the East and the West, and the stages at which, even when reconciliation of differences is improbable and each may regard the other's mote as a beam, an understanding may be helped and perhaps effected by toleration of each other's weaknesses. Such toleration between individuals, classes, and races is a necessary element in the promotion of the happiness of human life.
The author's acknowledgments are due to those master minds and the publishers of their works, from which quotations are made to illustrate the similarity of idealism in the East and the West, and in ancient and modern thought.
CONTENTS
PAGE
PREFACE . . . . . . ix
CHAPTER I
EAST AND WEST .
No geographical distribution of morals — Different moral estimates of East and "West — As others see us (and themselves) — Lines of uniformity — Colour distinc- tion— Privileged complexion — Growth of the " colour problem " — A triumph of " Colonial rudeness " — Effects of Colonial example on Asia — Resistance to colour pre- judice— Colour influences in Indian society — Animosities undergoing mollification in East and West — Differences in Eastern and Western political upheavals — Differ- ences in social relations — Different standards of judg- ment— Treatment of women — The basis of authority — Western flattery of national vanity — Survival of anti- quated traditions — Minority rule — Irish and Indian parallels — The Press, East and West — Fashions in food and dress — Diet and valour — Basis of success, military and civil — Treatment of criminals — Eagerness for titles — Domestic contrasts — Beggars — Eastern and Western caste — Patriotism — Desire for peace — " Subject races " — Public salutations — Lynch law — Superstitious prac- tices— Gradual rapprochement of East and West — Decline of Asiatic combativeness — War is not without its uses — Appeals for sympathy — Preservation of good qualities of all races — Obedience and command — Homi- cidal maniacs — Ceremonial extravagance — Gorgeous raiment — Paradise and purgatory — The safety-valve of
xviii CONTENTS
PAGE
discussion— Aristos and Demos— Eival Powers — Moral emancipation — Gentleness towards the gentle sex — Eespect for the Mother— Eastern teaching— The problem of baths— Reconciliation of differences— Unifying factors — Happiness the goal— Predominant characteristics: Eastern contemplation, Western action— Prominent hindrances to progress : Western intemperance, Eastern incontinence — Social misfits— Early marriage in the East — Commercialism and crime — Want and sin —Control of offences— Law and Society— The essential unity of life.
CHAPTER II
THE BEITAINS OF THE EAST AND OF THE WEST . 63
Position of the British Empire — Britain's connection with India — Origin, not by conquest, but by trade — The sword held by more Indians than Europeans — Happy escape from French control — Difficulties under British rule — Conflicting policies — Attitude of European barristers in India — Unfortunate influence of the Mutiny — Preoccupations of Parliament and the Press — The Crown in closer touch with India — Suggestions for a good and progressive administration — Reactionary poUcy — Results of British education — Gains to England, real and unreal — Early British policy of education and freedom — Modern antipathies — Sham Imperialism — Reflex influences — The theory of inherited governing capacity — The ideal policy of unity under British prin- ciples— Reverence for authority — King George's visit — The Coronation Durbar — Colonial forwardness — The Viceroyalty — Warping influences — British loss from Indian connection — Protection or Free Trade ? — Dis- crimination between British and Indian interests — A great example of courageous policy — Peculiar status of British Indians — Monopoly and privilege — The leaven of reaction — The real nature of the new movement in India — Reciprocal influences — Deteriorating contact — Danger of abandoning the old policy of fair play and freedom — Indian questions and Party politics— All kicks and no pence — Colonial preferences — Colonial honours
CONTENTS xix
—The Tory leader's Colonial bribe— Anglo-Indians, wise and unwise— Miscarriage of justice— " Cheap homicide "—Condonation of crimes— Illustrative ex- amples of insult and unmannerliness— Judges, Euro- pean and Indian— Official partiality—" My lords "— Army and Navy officers— The finger-print system— The " coolie " level— Colonial caste— Deterioration of manners under Colonial example— Colonial dislike and oppressive treatment of Asiatics— Connivance of British statesmen—" Kith and kin "— " Statesmanship of the British race "—Widespread mischief of Colonial arro- gance— Colonial privileges and aspirations— The true position of the Colonies— India's duty— Britain's neglect — Revolution in British Indian policy— Responsibility of electors — and of Ministers— Western discrimination against Asiatics— Imperialism transformed— Effects of military successes— Real source of Indian discontent — Privilege v. People— The way of peace— A race dicta- torship preposterous — Unrest necessary for progress — Government's duty to direct it— Its actual aim— The mind of the masses — The educated mind — Curtailment of educational facilities for Indians in Britain — Indian Law students in London — Social intercourse— Forma- tion of character— Moral control— Tendencies of im- perial democracy — Reactionary Government measures — " Ruthless repression" — " Separatist imperialism " — New India — Political pariahs — Indian loyalty — "Im- perialism " divides the nation into hostile camps — A divided duty— The Nationahst Party— Lack of official leadership — Invincible prejudice of the bureaucracy — Fitness for self-government — Eligibility for the public services — Restricted permission to bear arms — India's tribute to Britain — Britain's tribute to India — Modern " conspirators " and European example — Military dis- crimination— Civil sectionalism — Tenure of high office — Wild talk of independence — Limitations of indepen- dence (in various countries) — Dependent position of India — Conditions of national revival — Weaknesses of democracy — Who shall govern? — No preference of origin — India's Prayer — Hindrances to cordial relation- ship by no means insurmountable — Recent concessions a step forward — " Divide and rule " — Devotion to the
FA6B
XX CONTENTS
PAGE
Motherland and personal ability the true tests for pro- motion— Working of Council majority — Conditions of material progress — Proposal for a Consultative As- sembly on social and religious matters — Bevival of Panchayet system — Mutual confidence necessary — Peace and justice the true interests — Reserves on both sides — Culture removes social barriers — Position of women — India the only Imperial field for the develop- ment of great ideals — Sane imperialism is political idealism.
CHAPTER III
EASTERN AND WESTERN THOUGHT : PARALLEL
ILLUSTRATIONS ..... 216
Eastern and Western ideals and some illustrative parallels.
M. O. (HARV'W
ORIENT AND OCCIDENT
CHAPTER I
EAST AND WEST
Among certain types of mind that are bent upon dividing mankind into rival or antagonistic camps, Asia has, in modern parlance, come to stand for the East, and Europe and its offshoots, even when morally and physically farther away from Europe than Asia itself, for the West. A few among such minds are generous enough at times to attribute some virtues to Asia, and are also even candid enough to acknowledge some defects in Europe. But, taken as a whole, Asia has, owing to the loud trumpet-blast of its enemies and to its own humility, come to be regarded by Europeans in general as the nursery of every imaginable vice, and, by contrast, Europe necessarily becomes the home of all the virtues. It would doubtless be beneficial for mankind if even a comparatively small spot on earth or some single race could become a special repository of
2v
2 ORIENT AND OCCIDENT
virtue, in order to be able to hold aloft the torch of light and truth as a beacon for the guidance of the benighted spots and races. How much more beneficial would it be if a whole continent or a congeries of races endowed with a fair skin could rightly claim the position ! Those, how- ever, that lay claim for themselves and their kith and kin to all the virtues are always advocating dissimulation of or a lapse from the virtues in dealing with other races ; and the result naturally follows that the non-virtuous portions are apt to take all mankind to be like themselves and thus to miss improvement, while the virtuous portion, by contact with the non -virtuous and by practice, tends to recede from its own high standard.
Apart, however, from the absolutely prejudiced persons, whose numbers, owing to circumstances of the time, may be on the increase, the more thoughtful generally acknowledge that virtues or vices are not the monopoly or the distinguishing characteristic of any particular longitude or lati- tude, or of any one age or race. A view of the platform on which all sides of the mariner's compass— north, south, east, and west — and all ages of time— past, present, and future— unite, would readily convince observers that the same electric thrill influences every soul among man- kind according to the local conditions. The platform of animosities, appetites, passions,
EAST AND WEST 3
prejudices, and wickedness has been and will be common for a certain type of mind in all ages and climes. Equally common to the opposite type — the more virile and virtuous — has been and will be the platform on which that type has steadily and resolutely attempted to advance their fellow-men towards excellence. Wickedness in one sphere, and wisdom, like true and unsectarian religion, in another sphere, unify men in one brotherhood. It ought to be instructive to dis- ruptionists to note how the selfsame ideas have been promulgated, in varying forms and fullness, by minds that have flourished centuries or thousands of years apart from each other— ideas that ought by this time to have been universal in practice if the emissaries of darkness had not prevailed. Ages, Empires, and States have come and gone, but the thoughts of the great minds they produced are immortal : they will live to the end of time to illumine the path of those that are in need of light and life.
Persons of different temperaments give different explanations why East and West do not meet in friendly intercourse. The true explanation is that East is down and West is up, and until East goes up the two cannot meet without strain and injury to either or to both. Hence it has always been the aim of great minds to level up classes and races to avoid the evil consequences of contact.
4 ORIENT AND OCCIDENT
The East is now showing signs of coming up again, and it is to be hoped that, as the East moves upwards, the turn of the wheel of fortune will not take the West downwards and leave man- kind in as sad a plight as before. Meantime, however, until East shows steadiness in its apparent upward tendency, Western facetiousness describes Eastern indifference in face of danger and death as a sign of immobility, while a similar demeanour under similar circumstances of Westerners becomes fortitude and defiance. Eastern resentment of bad manners or of crude treatment is called impertinence ; similar self- assertion of Westerns is called independence. Eastern objection to tyranny of rulers, or of supporters of rulers, is called disloyalty and anarchism ; in Westerns it is lauded as a rightful struggle for freedom. Eastern criticism of un- palatable legislation is called sedition and repressed without remorse ; Western resistance to Acts of Parliament, or incitement to civil war, rebellion, and violence, is— in the eyes of one political party at least— not inconsistent with loyalty and lawful opposition. Bloodshed, mas- sacre, burning of villages and farms, and other atrocities have in the world's history often been perpetrated in the name of religion or of order by professing Christians on co-religionists as well as on Jews and other non-Christians ; in quite
EAST AND WEST 6
recent times examples have Keen reported from Morocco, Tripoli, Persia, and China ; and they pass without comment or are deemed legitimate methods and excusable tactics of warfare : but, if any such practices be indulged in by Eastern soldiers, even in the heat of battle or of retalia- tion, they are unhesitatingly denounced as barbarities. When Western troops are fighting Eastern, good care is taken to report such prac- tices as may rouse the sympathy of the civilized world on their side : the East rarely gets a correspondent who has the courage to proclaim the actual facts in the teeth of the prevailing atmosphere. Eastern religiousness is called superstitious weakness ; Western religiousness is designated humanitarian Christianity. In Easterns politeness and anxiety to avoid contra- diction becomes sycophancy ; in Westerns it is known as high breeding. The great virtue of the spirit of Eastern resignation becomes an object of Western ridicule, as it appears to a great lady in Shakespeare when anxious for vengeance :—
** Call it not patience, Gaunt ; it is despair."
What in Westerns would be patience is in Easterns described as timidity.
So long as the same mental or physical attitude or attribute becomes an object of praise or of blame according to the latitude or the longi-
6 ORIENT AND OCCIDENT
tude where it appears, cordial fellowship or even bare association cannot be expected. Uniformity in outward appearance or costume is, in the opinion of some people, needed for mental har- mony. These amiable people may think that by the extensive, if not universal, adoption of the European " bowler " hat Japan came into line with the West, and that the rest of Asia will have to do the same— as Young China, with the dread of the Empress-Dowager's edicts with- drawn, seems bent upon doing. Others may think that conversion to Christianity will have the same effect on Asia as it has had on Europe. Yet others are of opinion that, as the skin of the great nations of Eastern and Southern Asia can- not be as white as that of Northern European races, no meeting is possible. Colour and other superficial prejudice is a plant of com- paratively modern growth : it does not appear to have existed among the great races of ancient times, among whom there were lords and slaves of all complexions and costumes.
A scientist has recently expressed the view that primitive man was of a dark colour, and that the evolution of the lighter-skinned races was, biologically speaking, a comparatively recent event. If this theory is correct, the human skin, like the hair on the body, undergoes a change by time, being in the early stages light, as in infancy,
EAST AND WEST 7
then more and more dark-coloured with growth of body, and becoming gradually colourless as one advances in years. In some cases, under acute agitation of mind, it turns grey in a few hours or days. The human skin has hitherto been known to undergo changes according to its exposure to the sun ; but, if it changes its colour by time and training, the present disqualification of dark complexion from which Asiatics suffer in international relationship will gradually disappear with the disappearance of their comparatively primitive nature and methods. As, however, some Asiatic races are anything but primitive, and had at one time (if ancient tradition may be believed) a high degree of culture and refine- ment, as well as a fair complexion, it is worth while for scientists to inquire whether races, when they decay or revert to a primitive stage, lose lightness of skin and become gradually quite black like the negro. If it is so, the West, proud of its white skin, ought to be careful not to fall into decay or to recede into the primitive stage, as it is in danger of doing by contact with back- ward or inferior races. If, however, it is the case, as some Europeans assert, that white skins are alone amenable to civilization, and if science can show that the colour of the skin is influenced by the cultivation of the mind— not individually but racially— mankind need not fear an extinc-
8 ORIENT AND OCCIDENT
tion of its civilization, for there will always be some race with a comparatively high culture and a white skin.
The appearance in the streets of London and Paris of an increasing number of Africans, and the apparent fancy taken to them by some of unimperialised European womanhood, seem, from writings in the Press, to have the same disturbing effect upon the soft brain of a certain type of imperialist as the presence of British Indian students has upon a similar type of retired Anglo - Indians. While such imperialists advocate an indefinite expansion of empire, hoping thereby to ease the financial stress of friends, yet with strange inconsistency they cannot bear the sight of the people over whom power is to be exercised, and in whose country men of their type seek opportunities of fortune and fame. They appear to imagine that they will advance imperialism by applying in Britain, as is done in South Africa and in some parts of India, the tyrannical pro- cess of preventing the people over whom imperial sway is exercised from using the public roads and conveyances on equal terms with the modern privileged complexion.
East and West have through Colonial influence also come to stand in the eyes of European democracy for black and white, and what is called the " colour problem," before the solution
EAST AND WEST 9
of the " blood problem," has begun to exercise considerable influence on modern human relation- ship. It did not become acute so long as only the higher and more cultured classes of Europe, who were conversant with the origin of races and with the antiquity of Asiatic races, came in contact with people of non -white complexion, and so long as only a very few of the latter, and those of the better-bred class, were visible in Europe. Democracy, steam, electricity, and competition have let loose all classes in considerable numbers all over the world, many of whom, not having heard or read the names of other races or not being able to distinguish one from another, call them by the complexion, which strikes the eye. When the complexion is the same, but feature or language is difl"erent, " furriner " is the term applied in Europe and " feringhi " in Asia, half in fun and half in contempt ; and when com- plexion, as well as language and feature, is different, the term is changed to black, red, yellow, brown, or white. As before the fall of Aryanism in India the Brahmins succeeded in placing all other castes in one subordinate category, so the triumphant " white " man appears to be succeeding in dividing mankind into coloured and colourless.
The terms white and black as applied to skin may be suitable in the United States. Citizens
10 ORIENT AND OCCIDENT
there of whatever origin, being all Americans and Christians, have no other distinguishing name than white or black ; but the importation of this distinction into the Old World, or into the British Empire with its wide variety of races, nationalities, and religious persuasions, is a triumph of Colonial rudeness, which, if continued, will considerably influence the relationship of Asia and Europe. In the United Kingdom the separate nationalities are called English, Scottish, Welsh, and Irish ; and, to be consistent, the other races that make up the Empire may, by cultured people at any rate, be described as Canadians, Australians, Indians or Asiatics, and Africans. The use of any other designation or form of expression is simply a wicked means to perpetuate animosities and to nurse the seed of disruption. Asia, having been in its dormant state a field of amusement as well as of exploitation for non- Asiatics, is now in for a period of bad treatment at the hands not only of Colonials but of Europeans also, simply because bad example is more contagious than good. That treatment ought to develop all the finest qualities of Asiatic nature, and will, it is to be hoped, not infect Asia with foreign manners, nor lead even the more revengeful Asiatics to rejoice at the un- toward consequences to Europe of succumbing to Colonial example. The influence of that
EAST AND WEST 11
example is apparent in the changed manners of the aristocracy and of the middle class, and it is bound sooner or later to infect the toiling masses. As a matter of fact it is noticeable in daily life that the vast majority of men and women are above these frivolous prejudices, and that such prejudice is aroused only when an individual instrument of evil sets to work to inflame passion and hatred. There have been cases where the attempt to excite animosity has been nipped in the bud by a single just and resolute individual, who has put his foot down on such insane behaviour. When, therefore, it is announced that British Indians are receiving unkind treatment either in the Colonies or in Britain or even in India itself, it is ominous evidence that just and resolute individuals are becoming scarce in the present dominant sections of mankind. Such being the case, the oppressed peoples have the game in their hands if, instead of imitating the intoxication and vanity of the oppressor, they set themselves to cultivate the humane, just, and generous sentiments that raise existence to a higher atmosphere. Unrest continues and leads to progress in Europe because all the races and classes inhabiting it have not yet secured justice. In Asia it has commenced with racial privilege, and it will develop as in the West into a struggle with class domination. The first Trade Union
12 ORIENT AND OCCIDENT
has just been started in China among silversmiths whose employers have had to give in to their demands of an eleven-hours day and a 40 per cent, rise in wages. How recent is the triumph of toleration in Europe is apparent from the fact that Jews were not long ago excluded from membership of the London Stock Exchange, and had more recently on applying for admission to pay a heavy fine or premium, which is now abolished.
The prejudice that fair skins have always enter- tained against the dark is comprehensible on the ground of handsome men treating ugly men with indifference and scant courtesy, especially because they do not become formidable rivals for the favours of the gentle sex. That prejudice, although modified and supplanted by the intro- duction of caste, still prevails in India, imported probably by the white-skinned Aryans. It appears in matrimonial alliances, when parents prefer (within caste rules) a light complexion and hand- some match for their son or daughter. The principle in such match-making is explained in the couplet —
Kanya barayate riipam mata bittam pita srutam Bandhavah kulam ichchhanti mishtannam itare janah.
Bride prizes handsome husband ; mother prizes wealth for her son-in-law ; father seeks learning ; friends prize good family, and others a feast.
EAST AND WEST 13
The prejudice, however, is never carried to the extent of animosity.
In several departments of life there may lie a difference between the East and the West, as differences exist in the dispositions, idiosyn- crasies, and natures of individuals and of classes in the West itself. People are naturally indis- posed to commit crimes or even to assail and kill enemies with or without provocation, unless the brain is intoxicated and the mind loses its balance. In the East, intoxication of the brain has hitherto been produced, as it used to be in the West and is still among the more bigoted, by religious fanaticism. In the West, with the decay of fanaticism, the intoxication is produced by liquor. In both the East and the West, the balance of mind is lost and conscience is blunted among the more selfish by greed of gold. Animosities in the East will grow less in pro- portion to the advancement of education and toleration ; in the West, people will become more humane and dutiful with greater observance of temperance as well as of religious toleration ; while in both, crimes will be less frequent with improvement in the social conditions of the poorer classes and with more disparagement of the worship of mammon.
In the West, personal insults to individuals for obscurity of birth have almost disappeared, owing
14 ORIENT AND OCCIDENT
to progressive and democratic teaching ; in the East, they thrive like weeds, especially at the hands of natives of the West, some of whom find there the chance of asserting their aristocratic or divine attributes, and regard all natives of the East as occupying a lower category than domestic animals, for whose protection against cruelty societies are instituted. Retaliation for unkind treatment by superiors or by foreigners is almost unknown in the East ; in the West, scarcely a man or woman would stand offensive or even unmannerly conduct on the part of anj^ person however highly placed in life, while everybody deems it prudent not to provoke stronger muscles to action.
In the West, the educated people that care for public life are joyfully welcomed into the circle of rulers ; in large portions of the East, tliey are still regarded as intruders into the preserves of those that have hitherto monopolized all power. In the West, Governments exist for the advance- ment of national well-being, and thrive so long as they secure popular support by convincing the people that their aim is to make the people happier ; in the East, anything tending to foster national consciousness is deemed objectionable as likely to increase and to complicate the problems of government. When revolutions break out in the West, monarchs have to fly into
EAST AND WEST 15
exile for fear of being beheaded, and may always count upon support from a portion of the people in attempts to regain their thrones ; in the East, monarchs, when dethroned, quietly walk out of their palaces, like Sultan Hamid, the King of Burmah, and deposed Indian chiefs, and live in retirement in their own country, or, as has happened in China, they set up by their own edicts a different form of government and nomi- nate their successors. If Western monarchs had always been as wise and liberal as King Alfonso XIII of Spain has shown himself to be, owing probably to his relationship with the Royal House of Britain, they might have saved not only their heads but their thrones as well. Who would have thought it possible that a European king would, like King Alfonso, receive in audience at his palace the leader of the Republican Party? In the West, fear of or respect for monarchs, rulers, noble birth, or authority in general has disappeared, and in its place monarchs, rulers, and authority have to mould their conduct and policy and even their words according to the will of the pushful and organized sections of the people. In the East, veneration for authority and seniors is still a cardinal principle of life, but it is being undermined by contact with the Western teaching of equality, while in the place of indi- vidual despotism the tyranny of thousands of
16 ORIENT AND OCCIDENT
persons and of whole races, so long as they are of European descent, is being encouraged. In the West, impatience of control, as well as absence of consideration for others, has come to be deemed independence ; in the East, the thoughtful and cultured classes still think that it is impos- sible to live in society without dependence on others in one form or another, and that inde- pendence or freedom can be achieved in life only by asceticism or by complete control over the passions and appetites, since so long as man has wants to satisfy he has to depend upon others, even when the wants can be satisfied by coercion or by unfair exchange.
It is human nature to judge others by one's own standard. In the West, in spite of its high cul- ture and its advancement in various departments of life, mankind is deemed incapable of shaking off its brutal selfishness ; and for that reason every State has to drain a great deal of its life- blood and resources in preparing to slaughter its potential enemies and to avoid being slaughtered by them. The sensible course of training all individual entities in a nation to be honest, reso- lute, and self-reliant, and to have a horror of all forms of crime and treason, is as yet far from being attained. The East always believed, until recent times when the West shattered its belief, that mankind could be made saints and philo-
EAST AND WEST 17
sophers, and that to live in placid self- complacency is the way to secure peace. Hos- pitality to strangers is almost unknown in the West : with the selfishness characteristic of muscular development, with the opulence and luxury of the wealthy classes and the comparative poverty of the lower classes, and with the wide diffusion of the notion of equality, which presents the contrast in a glaring and provocative manner, every stranger has to be regarded with suspicion until he proves his trustworthiness. In the East, to refuse hospitality to one that comes to the door — even were he an enemy — is considered as heinous an offence as disrespect towards superiors. In the East, authority deems itself so infallible that even the slightest attempt to criticize it or to question its absolutism is met with stern repression— the eastern countries of Europe being in that matter like the East— and, in addition, it is part of the business of some guardians of law and order to concoct false charges for personal advancement as well as for discouraging the development of a spirit of inde- pendence. In the West, authority is so afraid of Demos that, even when Peers and Privy Coun- cillors incite to rebellion and revolution, when combinations of labourers break their contracts and resort to violence, when strikes take place to force the reinstatement of railway servants
3
18 ORIENT AND OCCIDENT
dismissed for drunkenness, it hesitates to use the strength of the State to assert law and order. The West does not tolerate individual despotism either of a monarch or of a minister, but it acquiesces in the imposition of the despotism and tyranny of thousands of its " kith and kin " over backward fellow -creatures of the East.
In the East, women have been trained to think that it is immodest to associate familiarly with or even to be stared at by men. In the West, women have gradually been taught to be the rivals of men and to oust them from their mono- poly of political power, and have taken to assault ministers of the Crown and to commit other out- rages in order to prove their fitness to be the rivals of men. On the other hand, the non- Christian East has hitherto been notorious for unchivalrous treatment of the gentle sex ; but the savage ferocity with which suffragettes are being treated in public places and at political meetings in the most tolerant and advanced of Western countries seems to indicate that ideas of chivalry prevail only so long as its objects remain meek, forbearing, and unpushful.
In political government the East still continues to believe in personal rule and class domination, not only because authority has by tradition been exercised by individuals and a few families, but
EAST AND WEST 19
also because, Eastern life being still based on religiousness, fear of and reverence for temporal regulators of society appear to be as necessary for the preservation of order as veneration of Godhead is an indispensable condition of religion and humanity. As a consequence of successful revolutions, the West is attempting to shake oil the idea of personal and unquestioned authority and to base it on popular sanction — and caprice, but it has not yet wholly shaken off the tradition of the importance of birth in human affairs. The democratic principle can conduce to the welfare of human society in proportion as individual and class selfishness is controlled, and the possible despotism of an organized and wilful mob, in place of the old form of tyranny, is avoided. Authority has to be vested in a few individuals, whether by birth, election, or nomination, and the risk of its demoralization both in the East and in the West can be minimized only by a high sense of duty and of responsibility. In the East, States decayed because despotic authority, being irremovable, ceased to be dutiful, while the level- ling tendency in the West runs the risk of taking away initiative from leadership. Both East and West are at the present day proving for the benefit of mankind that it is possible for non- elected authority to be patriotic and dutiful, while democracy has yet to prove its efficacy in main-
20 ORIENT AND OCCIDENT
taining order and in imparting to a State the moral and material strength based on unity, discipline, sense of duty, and, above all, originality.
In what is called the East— that is, among the ancients who invented and enjoyed the glamour of Imperialism— this consisted in conquering, tor- turing, and finally exterminating those that were Vk^eak and helpless. In the West, or in modern life generally, Imperialism, from which the idea of conquest, torture, and extermination has not altogether vanished, has added an additional injury both to itself and to its victim, rejoicing in abuse and vituperation and the trumpeting of its own excellence, in which the removal of the shackles of the Printing Press enables it to indulge. Imperialism in the West has advanced to the stage when it is difficult, if not impossible, for any one to expect to render service to his country or to humanity without profession of opinions that flatter national vanity and intoxicate the brain. Some holding lofty principles never- theless seek popularity by such opportunism, hoping to assert their principles after securing a position on the ladder, but, success being slow, constant practice of smothering innate tendencies weakens the principles. Others, high-born and high-bred, are obliged for personal usefulness to ofi'er the simulacrum of patronizing companion-
EAST AND WEST 21
ship to the lower orders, for whom they feel at heart a supreme contempt. These phases are as yet unknown in the East.
In the West, the aristocracy and plutocracy find their position so helpless that they are led to claim to be the bulwark of democracy, while among the proletariat combinations have been legalized as being necessary to defend their interests and to secure a happier life. In the East, the upper orders are still too proud and un- intelligent to attempt to conciliate the workers, while conspiracies are confined to the realm of authority, and, being hatched in the Council Chamber by holders of power, are deemed, so long as no foreign invader is at the gates to test their efficiency, master-strokes of statesmanship for the retention of existing prerogatives and for the demoralization of fellow-men. Those of the West that are opposed to the barbaric wickedness of war, and are in favour of humanized public life, no sooner come in touch with the East than they tend to become instruments for promoting forces that make for evil. Thus does the East help the West to retain in a corner of its heart antiquated traditions and methods that would otherwise be extinct.
In political life ideas of propriety are different, not merely in the conventional East and West, but also in the east and west of St. George's
22 ORIENT AND OCCIDENT
Channel. The Tory Press enunciates the right policy in Ireland as follows : —
" It is impossible for Ulster to submit to Home Eule, because under Home Eule Ulster would be in a permanent minority. A Catholic Nationalist Government would rule Ireland permanently. It could never be turned out. The Opposition could only protest ; it could never take over office. Thus a minority of one religion, one race, one industrial interest would be permanently under the heel of a majority of another race, another religion, and another set of economic interests."
Another important Tory organ recently pub- lished in large type a letter from " An Irish Whig " objecting to obedience to law as law and saying that " legalized oppression does not cease to be oppression, and that in that case the Inquisition in Spain and the Tribunal Revolu- tionnaire in France were regular and legitimate institutions." This implies that the Crown and Parliament of Britain have no more moral authority to pass Home Rule or any other controversial measure than the institutions named had to act as they did.
A prominent leader of Irish Toryism has also recently said : —
" I say that to ask any man to adopt and live under a Constitution which he has never had an opportunity of expressing his views upon amounts to a tyranny which is unparalleled in the history of civilization. (Cheers.)"
EAST AND WEST 23
From the above extracts and from the speeches and writings of other Tory leaders of opinion in the Press and on the platform it would appear that there is some considerable tendency in the West to return to the old idea still prevailing in the East, that a minority has the right to rule the majority, but not vice versa. Under the scheme of " reform " it has been adopted in recent British Indian policy, which has declared the minority composed of Moslems to be entitled to a larger voice in the Councils than the majority. The apparent object of this statesmanship — or at any rate its obvious result— is the same in both Ireland and India ; namely, to foster the intoxica- tion of a minority with a false idea of its import- ance, and to paralyse combined action in matters affecting the vital interests of the whole country and people.
To cool observers that favour human progress it must be a sad sight to notice the development of the new Western style in journalism as well as in political and social life. One could under- stand the difference in the old policy— on one side, protection of property and prerogative of birth, and, on the other, demand of equal oppor- tunities and happy conditions of life for all classes alike, high and humble. But when persons of light and leading, instead of teaching and trying to lead and to form public opinion, appeal and pander
24 ORIENT AND OCCIDENT
to passion and prejudice and wish to follow the imperfectly educated mass, civilization in the West does not set a good example to the East.
While it is very much more the exception than the rule to find in the public life of Europe a generous feeling for races of non-European descent, Asia, typical of the East, looks upon all races and creeds with absolute impartiality, how- ever much each race or creed may cherish a natural preference for its own self. In the West, the Press has become a power in forming indi- vidual opinion, but owing to the advance of democracy its appeal has been transferred from the leisured and well-to-do classes to the toiling masses that possess votes. In the East, the power of the Press is as yet meagre or non-existent.
In the West, food and clothing are regulated according to climate and to physical needs : by foreigners visiting or temporarily residing there they have to be adopted in order to avoid the unpleasant attentions of unsophisticated street boys and of uncouth men and women, as well as for physical reasons. The East has hitherto flourished on its own prescriptions ; but, as Paris fashions have come to dominate Europe, Western fashions in food and clothing, however unsuitable to the climate and environments, are now deemed necessary, not merely that one may pass for a civilized being, but also to command ordinary
EAST AND WEST 25
politeness from the lower official and labouring classes, who have been taught to show respect to the wearers of outlandish costumes, and indiffer- ence, if not positive disrespect, to those that prove themselves by their garb to be their own country- men. This is so because Westerns residing in the East prefer to undermine their health and vigour by retaining customs suited to a different climate, rather than to adopt outward forms that have come to be associated with an inferior stage of society and of life.
There is a notion among some persons — due probably to their own habits or experience — that a meat diet is necessary for physical development and well-being and also for moral courage. The greater portion of the East being dependent on rice, wheat, fruit, and vegetables, its dormancy was attributed to diet. After the display of singular courage, dash, and endurance by the Japanese— whose staple food is rice— in their war with a great Western Power whose people thrive on meat, and more recently (October, 1912) by the Servians, whose diet consists principally of wheat, rye, and maize, with oil and dried fruit, and who have been victorious over the meat- eating Turks, it would scarcely now be asserted by the most muscular meat-eater that his strength is due to his food, or that the dormancy of the East is due to its abstention from meat.
26 ORIENT AND OCCIDENT
The East, through many of the principles of theology it originated, has been prone to preach peace, patience, and forbearance. The West teaches that, while force cannot be dispensed with in human affairs, martial qualities play a vital part in the life and the honour of nations, and that traditional antipathies and antagonisms can- not be adjusted, any more than selfish instincts can be smothered, by the shrewdest diplomacy. The stakes for which rulers play— rulers despotic or democratic, in the East or in the West — are not only national wealth and the lives of their subjects, but also the permanent moral and physical welfare of their peoples, which is moulded by the policy pursued by the State. East and West, like the brute creation in all climes, are equally endowed with fighting quali- ties, but, while the West has gone ahead in the art of organization and is bent upon beating rivals in inventing instruments of slaughter, the perfec- tion of which in modern life is the only means of self-preservation, the East generally has re- mained stationary and has thus lagged behind, with the result of being unable to guard against assault its honour and its life. In modern war- fare an important and decisive battle is fought on ground extending over tens of miles and by enormous masses of combatants. Victory, there- fore, depends, not merely upon superior numbers
EAST AND WEST 27
or on the spirit, impetuosity, and dash of the rank and file, but also upon scientific generalship, upon the training of the officers, upon the intelli- gence displayed by each combatant, upon the arrangements for reinforcements and for supplies of ammunition and stores, upon medical help for the wounded, and, above all, upon superiority of artillery. With these valued possessions any country, whether in the East or the West, will come out of a war victorious.
In Turkey premature democracy and the conse- quent weakening of authority undermined even the traditional fighting qualities of the Turks, and the debacle witnessed in the last Balkan War in the autumn of 1912 led the enemies of the East to moralize on the incompetence and inefficiency of the Oriental. When Japan van- quished Russia, or when the German Confedera- tion conquered France, or when the United States drove Spain out of Cuba and the Philippines, the defeats were not ascribed by Oriental publicists, who would have been justified by Western example in so doing, to Occidental incapacity. Victory in war and success in civil life will, in East and in West alike, always attend those that are convinced— and act according to the convic- tion—that avoidance of self-indulgence is the secret of retention of virility.
In both East and West traditional ideas of
28 ORIENT AND OCCIDENT
vengeance still prevail in the treatment of crime, varying from positive brutality to comparative humanity. There are humane and far-seeing individuals that believe in justice being seasoned with mercy, and that are persuaded that ferocious punishments brutalize the legislator that sanctions them, the judge that inflicts them, the warder that practises them, as well as the criminal that endures them, however much the nature of his offence may deserve them. Humanity would be advanced and society would be benefited if, when punishments (which are in the nature of torture) are deemed necessary, the offender were sent to the gallows or the electric chair or the guillotine. Neither West nor East has yet been able to shake off all its brutal instincts and the taste of the sweetness of vengeance.
The West hopes to reduce human miseries by curbing the power of monarchs and rulers, and of the upper class generally, and by infusing into all classes the spirit of equality ; but, in spite of the general impatience of authority and of privilege, the appetite of moneyed people for titles (which were suitable in feudal times) and for inclusion in the privileged orders continues as insatiable as in the East, where the ambition of the well-to-do is to be dubbed Raja (King), though they may have neither the possessions nor the attributes appropriate to the title. Even
EAST AND WEST 29
in up-to-date republics and democracies across the Atlantic, where men are debarred from the acquisition of titles, not a few display eagerness to get naturalized in a European country to secure them, or are gratified when their sisters or daughters find titled European husbands.
To a dispassionate observer differences in moral and material characteristics between the Eastern and Western parts of the old world would appear no greater than between the East and the West of the European continent, between the East and the West of the Atlantic Ocean, between the East and the West of the New World, or even between the East End and the West End of London. In the matter of marriages and births, while the East retains its old ideas and tradition of un- restricted progeny, the West is thinking of easing the problem of human miseries by withdrawing from matrimony or by diminishing the numbers of people by exile to distant shores. Domestic service in the West being considered degrading, residence in flats and hotels is becoming wide- spread, and family life or housekeeping is being gradually g'ven up, while the annoyance caused by the presence of children is considered so great that, in addition to the increasing difficulty of securing dutiful nurses, whose assistance will alone permit evening enjoyments away from home, the objection of intending tenants to the
30 ORIENT AND OCCIDENT
contiguity of children is leading landlords to refuse tenancies to persons that have young children in their party. It looks as if people that are not their own landlords must make up their minds not to have children. In the East, children live and move with their parents day and night, however high the station in life of the parents may be ; in the West, the higher the position the greater is the segregation between parents and progeny. This isolation, by smother- ing tender feelings, leads to the development of independence witnessed in Western character. Marriage in the West is based on love, which is so deep that, as soon as the slightest incom- patibility arises, it is annulled by separation or dissolution ; among the ancient races of the East marriage is indissoluble even by death, and, although men may legally marry after the death of the first wife, her moral position and authority, can never be attained by her successors.
In the East, beggars, being physically weak for want of sustenance, are cringing and miserable and keep at a respectful distance, although by religious ordination and long usage a householder never refuses what help he can render to such unfortunate persons ; in the West, open begging is an offence, and beggars are sturdy and strong and display towards those of whom they beg as much independence as servants or other
EAST AND WEST 31
employees towards their employers, brush against ladies as well as gentlemen from whom they seek alms in the streets, and, except for the sight of a policeman, appear ready to snatch something unless their demand is met.
In the East, the higher castes have got into the habit of looking down upon the other strata of their community as inferior beings made by Providence to serve their betters as hewers of wood and drawers of water. Many members of the higher castes treat their humbler country- men kindly, but the^^ cannot, owing to social tradition, get rid of the notion that the proper place of the latter is just where they are. In the West, birth and wealth take the place of caste, and those that are endowed with these possessions regard their humbler compatriots as similarly made to toil away all their life without any hope of ease and comfort or even of satis- faction of necessai-y wants. In the West, how- ever, the higher orders are by circumstances compelled to profess considerable interest in the amelioration of the condition of the labouring class, though all the time opposing any measures for such amelioration. In both the East and the West a considerable amount of charity is often expended by those that do not take life to be intended only for pleasure and enjoyment, and that are impelled by motives not always
32 ORIENT AND OCCIDENT
of reward here or hereafter. In the West, both the high and the humble are now drifting towards a fresh re-arrangement of human society, a new caste composed of persons of European descent, who are to be in the position of Celestials to the rest of mankind— the mere homines— who have to live like the lower castes in the East or, like courtiers attending on the high and mighty, only to minister to the wants of the heaven-born Westerner and to intoxicate his brain with adulation.
The West, whether under autocratic or demo- cratic rule, has developed ardent patriotism, but as yet this is confined to a part, not extending beyond the circle within which its sympathies are bred. As in the eyes of aristocrats nobility is a gift of " high " birth alone and patriotism of the toiling class consists in devotion to them, so in the view of the West the East has no right to be patriotic or public-spirited, its proper role being, not dutifulness to the motherland, but devotion to the foreigner. The East, however^ has recently commenced to imbibe the spirit of patriotism, and is, on account of its humanitarian instincts, bound to develop it to a wider sphere than the West seems disposed to do. In the West, retired Army and Navy commanders with dis- tinguished service behind them deem it patriotic to attack their own Government, to proclaim
EAST AND WEST 33
national weakness, and to instigate international animosities ; the East has not yet arrived at this stage of civilized development.
The denial of justice turns people of the West into revolutionaries, who by violent methods extort from their rulers the rights they claim ; in the East, such denial is expected to make people loyal and law-abiding. A long peace and its attendant luxuries, combined with the absence of rivalry, led the pushfulness and virility of the East to slumber ; the West, in its anxiety to secure everlasting peace from those it dreads, is getting to be afraid of war and showing its keenness to conciliate rivals from whom danger is apprehended. It does not yet recognize the in- consistency of that attitude with riding the high horse before mortals that cannot do physical harm, or with courting the mockery of enemies that it wishes to pacify, thus proving to man- kind that strength and power to hurt continue to be the passports to consideration. The East has for some centuries appreciated, in preference to toil, a life of ease, which all classes and races of the West are now so anxious to secure.
It is the fashion among a certain type of Western politicians and journalists, now that there are no longer subject classes in their own country, to speak of " subject races." They are the analogues of the extreme social bigots among
4
34 ORIENT AND OCCIDENT
the Hindus, who feel so proud of their obstinate orthodoxy and so anxious to prove their social importance as to be the most inveterate oppo- nents and persecutors of those Hindus that dis- play any courage or initiative in social reform. Except in those colonies where recent states- manship has set up— with what results time will show— a dominant or enfranchised section and a subject or voiceless portion of the community, dominant and subject races have hitherto been unknown in the East, even in parts under the political sway of the West ; for the voiceless portion consists of all races and creeds, some enjoying greater freedom of expression than others, and some having greater privileges as criminals than others, but in the matter of en- franchisement, or political or social domination, all are in the same boat. People, when they talk of dominant and subject races, do not give a thought to the real position. In some countries political institutions are more or less despotic, in others they are more or less democratic. In India they are still despotic. The enfranchised European, the arrogant Colonial, and the " free- born " American have all on arrival in India to belong to the " subject race," while the British Indian and other British subjects enjoy in Britain the privilege of being electors on the same terms as those born or naturalized in the country. The
EAST AND WEST 35
people of India may with as much reason be called a subject race, because they do not elect their rulers, as could thirty-seven millions out of the forty-five millions of the inhabitants of the British Isles be included among " subject races " because only eight millions are on the electoral roll.
Osculation in public is not considered genteel in the East, and even a shake of the hand is rare, but a physical embrace, such as is indulged in by continental sovereigns and nobility, has from immemorial time been the symbol of friendly salutation. In Russia, which stands between the East and the West, kissing in public even by engaged couples entails punishment by fine. In the West, public display in various ways by couples in affectionate relationship is common, and in the transatlantic West has become so pronounced, without due regard to time and place, that notices have begun to be put up at cemeteries— the latest being at Germantown, Penn- sylvania—that " Flirting is prohibited." With a denial of matrimonial bliss, the desire to ignore observers when opportunities present themselves for indulgence in happiness seems to be becoming rather strong.
How infectious an atmosphere of love or hatred may become is proved in the matter of lynch -law, which originated in the far West and is slowly
36 ORIENT AND OCCIDENT
extending elsewhere. In its home it is no longer confined to negroes, nor even to men ; but lynch- ing a girl for tempting a man's affection seems to displa}^ a peculiar phase of Far Western en- lightenment. It was recently reported that at Darson City, Georgia, a clerk of the Supreme Court with the help of a friend forced a young woman into a motor-car, drove her to a lonely spot, bound and gagged her, and horsewhipped her almost to the point of death for having fascinated his son and enticed him away from home. Criminal Law Amendment Acts will shortly need further amendment in everj^ Western country so as to bring under the law girl " criminals " that entice away and tamper with the dutifulness of young hopefuls.
There is a common notion that superstition is confined to the East, and especially to " idolaters." It does not appear to be generally known, as was declared recently by a professor, that one-fourth of the school children of London wear amulets under their clothing. At a public meeting a distinguished peer of the realm confessed to carrying a mascot in the shape of a golden swastika— a custom which is said to be common nowadays. The general use of the horseshoe as a sign of luck is well known. Superstition may be observable in the East oftener and in more numerous affairs of daily life, but it is scarcely
EAST AND WEST 37
consistent for Westerners to point the finger of scorn when the difference in this matter between West and East is one in degree and not in kind.
In obstinacy and pugnacity the West may hold the palm, while in tenacity the East may boast of its strength, as shown in withstanding the attempted obliteration of its civilization and tendencies. Both may, like old and new creations in the peerage, or like old and fresh school -children, hold aloof from each other for a time, but acquaintance, contact, and sympathy based on the great productions of virile minds of the past, present, and future cannot, any more than the advance of know- ledge, be prevented. Many more strange miracles have been performed among mankind than the cordial understanding of East and West, or of rival nationalities in Europe, which reaction- aries consider impracticable. East and West commenced their acquaintance w^hen the spirit of adventure led European discoverers and merchants to the " gorgeous East." The acquaintance led to flirtation when European scholars in the eighteenth century took up the study of Eastern literature. The flirtation developed into an engagement when the Sovereign of Britain assumed direct sway over India ; and the tie was strengthened when in recent years Britain formed an alliance with
200025
38 ORIENT AND OCCIDENT
victorious and Imperial Japan. Whether the engagement will end with a solid matrimonial relationship or with a breach of promise depends upon the men and women that may for the next generation or two guide the destinies of the East and the West, The influence for good upon those men and women will be the per- ception of the unity of the higher thought that has always pervaded Asia and Europe.
With the " imperial " vision characteristic of worldliness, with the incapacity to understand human motives that is natural to the unsympa- thetic mind, and with the intoxication generated by success, non-Asiatics are, as a rule, unable to grasp Asiatic nature, character, and aims. Long peace unfits individuals and nations for wars ; long disuse of any faculty sends it to sleep. Asiatic nations, owing to immunity from foreign invasions for centuries, lost their pug- nacity and pushfulness, for which there had ceased to be further occasion. The arts of peace and good nature were cultivated, with the result that when invasion came the people and their rulers were found to have lost their combativeness. As in society and every-day life the presence of would-be criminals, thieves, and robbers necessi- tates caution and alertness, so in national life vigilance is indispensable for progress. If people wish to tackle the vultures that in
EAST AND WEST 39
individual and national existence are always prowling about for prey, they must cultivate the vulture's eye. Asiatic nature, getting fond of peace and ease, lost its vulture's vision, and became the target of foreign invasion and foreign taunts.
Wars are not among the desirable things of life, owing to the miseries they bring upon innocent people and to the diversion of human energies to the perfection of the art of slaughter ; but, until human selfishness and animosity are entirely uprooted, misery and desolation for a time — and extermination, if need be— are prefer- able to the eternal torture of foreign invasion or of antipathetic domination which bluntness of warlike faculties causes. Until, therefore, mankind as a whole becomes peaceful and divine, any nation that wishes to retain free- dom of development and to receive courteous treatment has to continue prepared for war, and even to seek occasion to make war on and, if possible, to cripple such rivals as threaten its security and independence. A great war used to be undertaken once in a generation in the East, when a new sovereign ascended the throne, in order to keep the nation in a state of military efficiency. Various European States have proved in modern times that it is a desirable policy, and that even a disastrous war may do a country,
40 ORIENT AND OCCIDENT
good in some direction, as disaster leads it to awaken from self-complacency and to initiate reforms. A successful war that crushes an enemy out of existence is scarcely desirable, since it takes away the need for continuous develop- ment of virility and sends the victor to sleep and self-indulgence, to which Asia was sent by success and peace.
In important centres of thought appeals are now and again made for the growth of sympathy between the East and the West, between Asia and Europe, between the ruler and the ruled. The very need for such appeals proves that there is something wanting in the relationship and mutual intercourse which the highest authorities cannot make good. Sympathy can only follow know- ledge ; knowledge is possible only where there is intercourse ; intercourse can take place only where there is mutual respect ; mutual respect results from good manners. For a generation or longer good breeding and manners have been slowly disappearing from the demeanour of the foreign residents, and have also been discouraged among Asiatics by taunts of servility and sycophancy. It is strangely rare to find a foreigner, even when he is liberal-minded and professes anxiety for the advancement of the Indian people, who does not at times show by. his words or acts the low opinion he holds of
EAST AND WEST 41
the people, whose standards of life and conduct are taken to be different from his own.
Gentleness and consideration are the peculiar characteristics of the East, as overbearing and rudeness, miscalled independence, and not un- frequently deserving to be called insolence, are products of the West. If East is to remain East, the only way to compass this would be to prevent the evil products of the West from being im- ported into the East. If there is anything in the East that the West does not like to have introduced into its domain, then there must be avoidance of contact. There exist, however, both in the East and in the West, or in either, quali- ties that may profitably be retained or that one or the other would like to acquire. It would be a splendid achievement of the human mind if the best men and women of both East and West, both North and South, could combine to found an organization in which, without sacri- ficing national interests and traits, only the good qualities of all the races of men would be dis- played and fostered for the benefit of mankind, and the evil instincts of the mind would be unknown, or at least held in subjection. The policy initiated by some new States of excluding " undesirable aliens " may in such an organiza- tion be so developed as practically to extinguish all chance of evil contact. The members of such
42 ORIENT AND OCCIDENT
a body would easily perceive that Providence devises human instruments for rewarding virtue and punishing wrongdoing, however much the instruments may indulge in the conceit of believing in their own capacity for meting out the deserved reward or punishment. Both East and West furnish proofs of such action. To curb the conceit of the East, priestcraft and religious bigotry came into existence, with the result of dragging the Eastern man to destruction. In the West, apart from national calamities and disasters occasioned by conceit, labour unrest, as the result of the greed of gain and desire for monopoly of the capitalist and well-to-do classes, combined with the ascription of divinity to European birth, appears to have been devised by Providence for curbing Western conceit, unless the virile portion of the West wake it up in time to save itself from ruin.
In one matter there is a specially noticeable difference between the East and the West. A great historical character in Shakespeare says : —
** The hearts of princes kiss obedience, So much they love it."
But in Asia generally, and in India specially, the hearts of " princes " love obedience so much as to find amusement in kicking and killing it,
EAST AND WEST 43
and non -Asiatics catch the contagion on arrival in Asia. It would be a blessing for mankind if in both East and West obedience to duly con- stituted authority and worthy mastery could be retained without intoxicating the holder of power and deadening his sense of humanity and justice. In the West, when homicidal maniacs or organized conspiracies, like that of militant suffragettes, make a target of prominent indi- viduals— of Kings, Emperors, Presidents of Republics, or Ministers of State — they do not upset the even course of administration and legislation ; reactionary venom deems it prudent not to assail the race or even the family out of which the assassins spring, and, after regular trial, they meet with their deserts. In the East, where hitherto such mania has been unknown until its recent importation from the West, attempted or successful assassination of officials, high or low — the East being still in tutelage, the target, happily, is generally missed — entails serious consequences for the entire popula- tion, all of whom, if not taken to be abettors or connivers, become fit subjects for reactionary ridicule and suspects for failing to catch the offender. Eastern people may inquire why they are dragooned and pilloried for the acts of miscreants when the shades of Charles I, Louis XVI, Alexander II, Abraham Lincoln,
44 ORIENT AND OCCIDENT
Humbert, Carnot, Carlos, Lord Frederick Caven- dish, and a host of other rulers of men, not to speak of noblemen in the dark ages of English and other European history, do not express surprise that the peoples from whom their assassins sprang have suffered no evil consequences for their atrocious crimes.
In some traits of character East and West retain a similarity. Persons in want, who find it difficult to make ends meet, are always ready to run into debt and to pledge their little posses- sions in order to be able to conduct a marriage ceremony or a funeral in grand style — or style unsuited to their means. If it were a matter merely of display — of attempting to be taken by neighbours as richer than the reality — it could be understood ; for that is an impulse charac- teristic in human intercourse. But people that in other matters do not hesitate to admit their financial difTiculties become in certain social functions extremely imprudent and extravagant. There are, of course, natural and historical con- siderations ; but, after all, the explanation may lie in the fact that marriages and funerals are functions where female influence preponder- ates and where theology and priestcraft play a part — woman being by nature generally re- ligious, and by habit unused to calculate financial ways and means, while priests take care to exact
EAST AND WEST 45
ceremonial dues. Thus in some matters of life East and West are at one in admitting the right of the gentle sex— and of the priest — to rule.
Fondness for gorgeous raiment is another weakness common to East and West. In spite of Nature's law that, while beauty and grace are the attributes of the female, the male kind in the winged species is more brilliantly adorned with plumage, and in the animal world is made more handsome than the female, gorgeous sartorial decoration for man has almost gone out of fashion in the West. It has now for a few generations been mainly confined to women and military officers and functionaries in State service on ceremonial occasions, and when worn by these it is deemed admirable. In the East, decoration of the male form is as common as that of the female ; but there Westerns repre- sent it as a sign of effeminacy. Acts were passed in Scotland in the reign of King James II, and in Spain in the reign of Alfonso X, to penalize extravagance in dress. No such law has yet been deemed necessary in the East, but if, owing to increase of wealth and to inability to find a suit- able use for it, luxuries and vain display become general, thoughtful legislators in both East and West may wish to find the means to control ex- travagance, not only in dress but also in food, marriage, and funeral expenses.
46 ORIENT AND OCCIDENT
Whatever differences between East and West may exist in the present-day ideas of life, the differences in the ideas of a future life would appear to be very little. Both believe in a Here- after in which punishments have to be undergone for evil acts and thoughts, and rewards will be gained by a life of virtue. Paradise and purgatory exist in both. Different schools of thought have explained them in various ways, but the central idea in both is that the enjoyment of heaven or suffering in hell is regulated accord- ing to the measure of virtue or of sin. Some believe that the processes of enjoyment and suffering are undergone in human life by trans- migration ; others place them in another exist- ence. The Aryan notion has explained the idea by placing the different stages of reward and punishment in seven heavens and seven hells, rising higher or descending lower according to the nature and degree of one's acts in life. According to both Eastern and Western notions man is endowed with freedom to do good or evil — to choose the course he wishes to follow. It would be a curious creation — not of the Author of all good but rather of the devil — if for deliberate evil acts for which no punishment is received in this life no suffering has ever to be borne.
The human mind from its peculiarly inquisitive
EAST AND WEST 47
and restless nature seeks diversion from its daily occupations in oral or mental discussions, at first playful but gradually becoming serious, which for the sake of self-glorification take the form of insistence upon the correctness of one's own view. Such insistence leads in social life to dissension for short or long periods. The discussions become common in the absence of more useful and urgent occupation. In the East, great stress was laid in the intellectual sphere on these dis- cussions, and they often led to mortal enmity. Recognition of capacity was made by authority through conferment of the title of Tarkaratna C Jewel of debate " ). In the politics of the West, the edge of harmful discussion is blunted and civil strife is averted by the circumstance that international differences necessitate the direction of all national energies to keeping the foreigner in check and to subduing him in the moral, intel- lectual, and economic spheres as well as in physical strength. Both in the East and in the West, in disputes and discussions when argument fails or the brain gets heated, people without sufficient self-control, and anxious for retaliation, resort to abuse or physical violence. There is often a mixture of both these, but when physical violence is deemed risky abuse in a form not to incur legal liabilities is the weapon of the weal^. Wise men in both the East and the West well
48 ORIENT AND OCCIDENT
know that until the function of the mind can be scotched, nationally as well as individually, it will have free scope for discussion and difference either abroad or at home, and that each nation, under the guidance of competent leaders and rulers, has to regulate its training and conduct according to what it deems beneficial.
There is a period in every nation's life when Aristos finds pleasure in encouraging the rise of Demos, but as Demos grows and displays unruly tendencies Aristos feels sorry fori having lent him a helping hand. If Aristos, instead of being disconcerted by the waywardness of a healthy fellow-creature whose growth he has promoted, were to keep his head cool and do his duty by his youthful comrade by taking Demos into gradual partnership, all would go well and Demos would continue loyal and grateful to his patron. But as in badly trained households natural changes bring into being a new generation both of Aristos and of Demos, the former becomes jealous of the growth of a rival, and the latter forgets his origin, and a struggle ensues threaten- ing a war of extermination, which, whether successful on one side or on the other, can end only in disaster. Continentally Europe and Asia now stand towards each other as Aristos and Demos in the West.
To avoid inanity and to perpetuate friendly
EAST AND WEST 49
emulation, without which human life is degraded to the brute creation, there must by the law of nature be two classes in every community and two great rival States among mankind. In ancient times there were Persia and Hellas ; next, Carthage and Rome ; later, Gaul and Saxon ; then, Spain and England ; and, in the nineteenth century, France and Britain. In all these cases the first named in each couple may be said to have represented the East or Oriental ideas, and the second the West. For Britain the tables are now turned. Long association with Asia and a world-wide Empire make her the greatest Asiatic Power, while another Power has now risen, as England rose in the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries, and is challenging Britain for mastery in human affairs. The rivalry between the East and the West is now represented by Britain and Germany. The latter apprehends danger to the West from the revival of Asiatic races whose championship Britain has, in spite of Germanized colonials, been forced by circumstances to take up. In moral ideas, however, the position is reversed, the Eastern Power standing for human advancement, the symbol of the West representing reaction and selfish greed.
The governments of European and other countries are introducing alien immigration laws, in imitation of the old Chinese policy of excluding
5
50 ORIENT AND OCCIDENT
foreigners of a certain type from their States. If Asia were to adopt this policy, it should not only exclude or deport those foreigners that by their conduct or manners prevent the growth of sympathy between Asia and the other Continents, but by suitable education point out to Asiatics the platform on which Asia is one with Europe and with mankind. Asia is learning from Europe that loyalty to any institution or individual can no longer be extorted by force or fear, but will be secured only on the ground of utility. Europe has also to teach Asia that any domination, native or foreign, oligarchic or democratic, is equally undesirable, unless it encourage or help the removal of the shackles of antiquated customs and traditions, which retard free development more than mere physical or political subjection. Apart from unity of thought, Asia has to assert unity with Europe in moral emancipation.
The East at its grandeur imparted to the West what it had to teach. In the whirligig of time it is now the pupil of the West and has a, great deal to learn in pushful pugnacity, in the arts of defence and offence, in scientific ideas and investigations, in political science, in precision of thought and expression. The triumph of the West has been secured by nothing so much as by gentleness and humanity towards the gentle sex. Those characteristics are threatened by the
EAST AND WEST 51
struggle for equality between the two sexes, initiated and prosecuted by a thoughtless type of mind. Before they disappear from the West, the East will do well to learn them, so as to keep these sublime qualities alive among man- kind. The West, although at present it has not much to learn from the East, may with advan- tage adopt the Eastern worship of the Mother in the homestead. In the West, as soon as a son is married, the mother, for the preservation of her self-respect and avoidance of rivalry between two mistresses, has to live apart from her son. The East would do well to reject this phase of Western life, but, as some evil invariably comes with good, India, where Western influence is most potent, is rather following the bad example.
Although the East is now in a state of tutelage to the West, yet on the principle enunciated by a sage—
Yuktiyuktam upddeyam vachanam balakadapi A reasonable advice from even a^child is acceptable
the West among other things has recently imbibed the notion of the necessity for physical cleanli- ness and health by daily ablution ; but not being quite prepared for it the West is placed in some difficulty. In the East, almost every bedroom has a bathroom attached to it. Space being limited in the West, enough bathrooms are not
52 ORIENT AND OCCIDENT
provided even for the well-to-do — not to speak of humbler classes— either in private houses, clubs, hotels, or on board ship, v^ith the result that considerable inconvenience is caused to those that have got into the habit of a morning dip or wash. Like the problem of street traffic, the problem of baths is becoming acute.
The West is attempting to solve the problem of human happiness by curtailing the powers of rulers and privileged oiders and by making the masses feel their importance and know their rights. In the place of despotic rulers peace and order will in future rest on the caprices and prejudices of despotic mobs. It would be a mis- fortune for mankind if the East tried prematurely to imitate the West in this form of solution of the problem of its miseries. Bet\veen East and West, as between North and South, or between Asia and Europe, there are differences caused both by natural and by artificial conditions which the thoughtless brain may deem it impossible to reconcile, as it considers the apparently antag- onistic interests of class and mass, of wealth and poverty, of leisure and labour, and of ruler and ruled, to be irreconcilable. The West does not encourage the spirit of abstraction, or total with- drawal of the mind from matter, which the East has always prized, but the East and the JWest equally admire and revere, what the West has so
EAST AND WEST 53
often displayed, courage ,and strength combined with generosity, humanity, and righteousness. In whichever part of the world these qualities pre- vail, it will be not only the dominant force, but also the leading instrument for good among mankind.
Enemies of human brotherhood, disruptionists and separatists, wish continents, nations, races, classes, and individuals to be morally as well as physically aloof from each other. One can be wholly apart from or uninfluenced by another only if, like the Gods in heaven and men on earth, the two were so separated as never for a moment to come in contact morally or physically. With the advance in speedy means of communication, with the anxiety of the adventurous and the inquisitive to discover and to know all about their fellow-men, and with the desire of the needy to find where their needs can be satisfied, continents and countries can no longer, any more than individuals and classes, be separated from each other, or avoid influencing each other for good or for evil. Misanthropes will always wish the evil to be communicated and the good to be hidden, as philanthropists wish the contrary. There are Asiatics that perhaps would like insolence, impertinence, and disrespect for authority to remain confined to Europe, as there are Europeans that would like Asiatics to be ignorant and submissive. The aim of the
54 ORIENT AND OCCIDENT
thoughtful idealist is to bring about a state of things in which contact will lead each side to reject the evil traits of the other and to blend the best characteristics of both. In past ages the light of wisdom, like the light of the sun, was the only beneficial and unifying factor among man- kind. It has, in recent times, been supplemented by scientific discoveries, which are bringing all parts of the world into close moral and physiqal relationship. Even reactionary blindness cannot for long avoid perceiving the difficulty, if not the impossibility, of keeping apart East from West and man from man ; and with such perception will be removed all obstruction to the extension to the physical world of the moral unification now existing in spirit and in the higher regions of thought in all lands.
While retaining its own peculiar characteristics inseparable from natural conditions, each will find, as culture advances and prejudice is over- come, that though East and West may, like North and South, difi'er in skin-colour, in social customs and habits, or in political institutions, yet East will be West and West East, whatever each term may be intended precisely to signify, when indi- vidual and corporate life is lifted above the promptings of self and its unity becomes apparent to mankind.
It is not intended, nor is it necessary, to refer to
EAST AND WEST 65
the scholarly discoveries of the resemblance between the forms of popular worship, on which conduct of life as well as wisdom was based among the ancient Greeks, Romans, and Hindus, or to the similarity of the religions of these peoples to the religions of countries so far apart as China, Egypt, Persia, Phoenicia, Phrygia, and Syria. The parallel between the gods of the Indian and of the European " heathens " was completely established by Asiatic researchers. These moral resemblances, like the household and warlike implements collected in museums, prove the unity of the human mind at a certain stage of its development. Long separation and want o| intercourse caused a strangeness culminating in a complete breach among the different branches of the human family, which modern science by closer intercourse is paving the way to heal. At even considerable distances of time, space, and environments, the unity of thought displayed in the quotations in Chapter III from the sublime productions of Oriental and Occidental sages must be held to be remarkable. Except for dif- ferences created by association, climate, and physical needs, all religion and all thought in all parts of the world lead to the same goal— the diminution of human misery caused by selfish- ness and the advancement of happiness through a feeling of unity.
56 ORIENT AND OCCIDENT
The East has been associated with contempla- tion and the West with action : these have been their several predominant characteristics. With- out some contemplation or some action it is impossible to live, but the best or ideal life is that in which action and contemplation are evenly balanced. A little more contemplation on the part of the Occident and a little more action in the Orient would bring them nearer together.
The great hindrance to progress in the West is intemperance ; in the East — especially in countries which have been under Moslem in- fluence—incontinence. Intemperance in the West is a weakness of a few persons that lose control over themselves by misfortune or bad company, and is mostly to be found among the ill -educated or ill-bred : incontinence in several countries of the East is not confined to the uneducated, and is the cause of all the miseries, moral and physical, which prevail there. Temperance in the West and continence in the East have always been encouraged by the most thoughtful and virile minds, and the more widely these virtues are practised the more will East and West be unified on the basis of duty and righteousness.
What havoc is caused in the West~b3^ liquor is indicated by the latest published statistics for France, where 10 per cent, of the total deaths are directly attributed to alcoholism— not simple
EAST AND WEST 57
drunkenness. It is estimated to be a contributory cause of 20 per cent, of the deaths. If similar inquiries could be instituted in India, a much higher percentage of deaths, and, indeed, most of the ills of life, would be found to be attributable to early marriage and incontinence.
How seriously social evils may prevail in the advanced West as in the backward East was recently brought to public notice at the Guildhall Conference on the Health of the City Worker. On that occasion the medical officer of health of a London district was reported to have said
" that the alienation between employer and employed is gradually growing, separating them into opposite camps; that girls on leaving school despise domestic service and take to factories or workshops ; that at the early age of eighteen or nineteen they get married, with disastrous results — husband and wife starting quarrels shortly after marriage, wife having no idea of house- keeping or of preparing meals, and, when family arrives, having as mother no idea of how to rear children, the bulk of them growing up delicate or dying in infancy; that there are plenty of unemployed men, yet women do work which Nature has not intended them to do."
Most of the evils mentioned exist in the East owing to early and compulsory marriage.
There are other social evils which are common to both East and West. Crimes of violence are not the monopoly of any land, and they are pro-
68 ORIENT AND OCCIDENT
ducts of commercialism as well as of want. While the East fell into lethargy and slumber, commer- cialism enabled the West to go ahead ; but, like surfeit producing illness, excess of commercialism threatens to drain modern life of its vitality and stamina. In the East, crimes of violence are generally committed in secrecy : in the West, with the development of greater freedom and fearlessness these crimes are taking place in broad daylight, and their increasing frequency in such centres of enlightenment, luxury, and wealth as London and Paris proves the risks that affluence runs in modern life when it is not shared by all classes. In addition to crime, recruits to the ranks of sin are enlisted through want. The East attempted to grapple with the evil by the institution of universal and early matrimony, but has failed owing to inattention to economic con- ditions. In the West, where the spread of educa- tion and independence might be expected to diminish the pest, recruits are drawn to sin through the disinclination to matrimony encouraged by various social causes, and through inadequate wages paid to women in all forms of labour, and especially in skilled trades. With the rise in the standard of life, distribution of the gains of industrial enterprise has to be regu- lated more fairly both in East and in West if those evils, as well as the allied faults of
EAST AND WEST 59
falsehood, theft, and dishonesty, are to be extirpated.
For these and some other vile offences the East used to prescribe torture : the West, after a period of humanity, seems to be relapsing into the state in which mutilation, the stake, and the tortures of bygone ages will alone satisfy the modern craving for vengeance and the refined thirst for blood — a result of contact with the East. Neither in the West nor in the East has the infliction of torture succeeded, nor will it ever succeed, in extirpating crime that the uncul- tured mind will commit, sometimes by calculation for selfish gain, and at other times by fits of passion when the reasoning faculty becomes dull. Crimes of calculation may be controlled by deterrent punishments, but crimes proceeding from sudden or momentary passion can never be expunged except by high culture.
Law is made, not for the honest, but for the criminally disposed. Without the law-breaker the law would lose its reverence, and, indeed, its very use : if everybody were good and dutiful no laws or courts of justice or even executive authorities would be needed. There is a type of adventurous mind that enjoys the delight of rebellion against law and authority, and it some- times, like Nelson, prospers by such resistance. Man's nature is to become full of good resolution
60 ORIENT AND OCCIDENT
at the prospect of seasonable punishment. It is imagined that some day capital will be so plentiful that the lenders, instead of expecting interest from the borrower, will be pleased to be relieved of their superfluous wealth. It should not be diffi- cult to imagine a time when goodness and honesty will be so widespread that the propensity of the mind towards furtive crime will need encourage- ment by the State, in order to keep alive the faculty to do wrong, which maintains the appre- ciation of good deeds. At present, under backward conditions of human society and in despotically governed States, whether in the West or in the East, the encouragement proceeds from Agents-provocateurs for their own praise and advancement. In addition to individual crimes, communal crimes under the name of lynch -law have long flourished in the West, where a com- munity impatient for vengeance inflicts punish- ment upon an offender before legal trial and conviction. This craving for vengeance has not yet appeared in the East, but in its place an equally ominous symptom is visible in the desire to punish, not a criminal wrongly acquitted, but the judge or magistrate that is supposed to dis- pense injustice. It will generally be noticed that, as extremes of temperature are bearable only in youth, extremes of revengeful ideas are specially palatable to minds not sobered by discipline and
EAST AND WEST 61
reason. While, on the one hand, the appetite of despotic and inhuman power over fellow-men grows by what it feeds on, on the other hand, perverted political passion adopts secret assas- sination as its mode of revenge on the wrong- doing of power. Unbalanced minds, whether in power or in insignificance, are notoriously thoughtless in their acts and unprepared for the exigencies of life, and thus they often reap the whirlwind that they deliberately sow.
The quotations in Chapter III would testify that in both temporal and spiritual life the idealism of^East and West, as expressed by some of their wisest sons, has been alike and uniform. The East commenced what the West more fully developed, but while the East withdrew more into contemplation the West advanced towards action. The problem for both in the present and in the immediate future is how to control the passions that impede liberty without destroying their usefulness, and how to secure free develop- ment without endangering the sense of justice. The solution of the problem depends upon the comprehension and exercise by an increasing number of men and women in every country of the principle enunciated by St. Paul in his Epistle to the Romans (xiii. 9), "Thou shaft love thy neighbour as thyself," and by Oriental sages in the maxim, " Atmavat sarvabhooteshu " (to look
62 ORIENT AND OCCIDENT
upon all creatures as one's own self), or " Sar- vatrotsrija bhedajnanani " (dissipate from the mind the sense of difference).
For champions of the theory and practice of inequality, differentiation, and separation, for beneficiaries from the privileged position con- ferred by birth or good luck, it must be painful to contemplate the principle of the essential unity pervading life, whatever the phases in which it is displayed- -the unity that humane theology in the first instance, and philosophy in the next stage, promulgated for the benefit of man, and that physical science has in recent years by remarkable discoveries been trying to establish. Even if the idea of physical unity be from visual differences deemed absurd and repul- sive, the separatist in the moments he can spare from amusements and complacency may cast a glance upon the thoughts of Eastern and Western sages and find in them the spiritual unity that pervades life to eternity. A sober separatist may also contemplate that East and West, being integral parts of one system, must influence each other for good or for evil, and that in the future, as in the past, the race, nation, or class that develops intellectual life, originality, personal initiative, and organizing capacity, will be the dominant factor in moulding human destiny.
!. M C BAMJER CHAPTER II
M. D. {Hcro'm :rrY Health Dept. THE BKITAINS
Of the East and of the West
Whatever irreconcilable differences in particular incidents of life may exist between the East and the West, the twain have, by a strange conqate- nation of circumstances and by inscrutable fate for good or for evil, met in the Empire of Britain, and no power on earth appears likely to be able to bring about a dissolution of their union or even a temporary separation. Under the cir- cumstances a comparison of the state of things in the different countries composing the Britains must be of deep interest, in the first place to all Britons, and next to all thoughtful observers anxious for the advancement and the happiness of mankind. The relationship of the Britains is of profound concern to Britons that either as rulers or as citizens — as players in the great drama of life— bear a hand in a prominent or in a humble sphere in rearing and sustaining the grand fabric that controls the present and im-
63
64 ORIENT AND OCCIDENT
mediate destiny of four hundred millions of Britons, in a somewhat remote degree that of hundreds of millions of human souls, and of perhaps two or three times that number in the future. Britain's connection with India brings her, and with her, owing to her liberal commercial policy, the rest of the West, into close relation- ship with the whole East, as it brings the East under the influence of the whole West. In spite of occasional misunderstandings and disagree- ments, which happen at times even in the best regulated households, the relationship cannot, even by pessimists, be described as un- pleasant or be condemned as unfortunate. Even if it were unpleasant or unfortunate, the wise course would be to make the best of what is unavoidable and to endeavour to remove the hindrances and to avoid the pitfalls that closely attend human steps and efforts. Despair and panic are phases unknown to the sober and virile mind, which is ever ready to gird up its loins and to display coolness in the dangers and trials that cannot be dissociated from human existence. When dark clouds lower and prospects look gloomy, when enemies rejoice and fools act after their kind, wise resolutions, taken without hesitation or timidity, and resourceful- ness, springing from a consciousness of honest and just motives, speedily bring about normal
THE BRITAINS 66
conditions and lead along right lines to the goal of abiding good.
There are persons in Britain, and these not confined to the ignorant or ill -read multitude, that assert that Britain's connection with India sprang from conquest, and that, having been acquired by the sword, it must always rest on the sword. Apart from the fact that every coun- try originally is conquered by the sword— that the Governments, the ruling families, or the upper classes of the most advanced and powerful States of the present day originally established their sway by conquest and by the might of their swords and had subsequently to take their con- quered into partnership— it ought to be apparent to the meanest understanding that physical force cannot in nature be long continued without a breakdown, and that history does not record a single instance in which a successful or conquer- ing class has long maintained its dominance with- out injury to itself or to the State. In those instances alone where the conquering or ruling order voluntarily shared some of its power with its subjects, or was compelled by circumstances to hold out to the conquered the hand of fellow- ship, have States avoided civil war or foreign conquest and continued to flourish. The con- nection of Britain with India began neither by conquest nor by the use of force. It originated
6
66 ORIENT AND OCCIDENT
with a few traders setting up factories by the grace of the Government of the day. Wars indeed followed. It was to the victor of Plassey that Shah Alum granted the Diwani (or governing power) of Bengal, which subsequently provided the counsel and the sinews of war that eventually brought the whole tract from the Himalayas to Cape Comorin under one orderly government. When the Mongol empire was crumbling to decay, a fighting Hindu tribe— the Mahratta — began to harass from the south the tottering regime and seemed to be making headway in restoring Hindu power and supremacy, while another homo- geneous Hindu sect was establishing a powerful state in the Punjab. Rival chiefs contending for mastery found adventurous French soldiers ready to take sides with the combatants. When English adventurers subsequently joined in the fray, the great Revolution and the unsettled position of affairs in France led to the weaken- ing of French power in India, and the English traders, being well backed from home, succeeded in bringing about the discomfiture of French influence. It should, however, be borne in mind that in the struggles for supremacy, whether between French and English or between European and Indian, the combatants were mostly, if not all, Indians with a sprinkling of European officers or gunners. The system of
THE BRITAINS 67
fighting the battles of a country by its own people, whatever may be the cause for which they were fought, was the invention oT French genius, and has since that time governed the policy of European States outside Europe, and even in Europe it was tried by Napoleon. Those that declare India to have been conquered and to be held by the sword choose to forget that the conquering sword was much more Indian than European, and that the sword that holds India for Britain is still in the hands of a larger number of Indians than of Europeans. Even if India had been acquired by the sword, reasonable minds will admit that, with the continuance of the British connection, with the gradual dawn of conscious- ness which that connection and the example of other countries must bring, and with the growth of patriotism and self-respect, reliance on force in dealing with people who are to be the step- ping stones to fortune and fame, but for whom human feelings are but rarely entertained, can scarcely be regarded as safe or wise.
It was fortunate for India that the English side triumphed ; for, although connection with France would after the Revolution have enabled India to send Deputies to the Chamber in Paris — as tiny French India still sends a Deputy and as Asiatic Russia sends Deputies to the Duma — the
68 ORIENT AND OCCIDENT
unsettlement of France for a century would have continued civil war and consequent anarchy in India, together with neglect of the interests of the Indian people. After a hundred years of struggle between democracy, militarism, and despotism France has obtained a settled government and institutions suited to her requirements ; but, as the institutions and the very safety of France herself depend upon the discipline and organiza- tion of a conscript army, and as the army itself forms the manhood of the nation, their strength cannot be tested except in war, which, if success- ful, may make the victorious commander a despot like Napoleon, and, if disastrous, may cause a revolution and sweep away the present regime. England is the only country in the modern world that combines the latest ideas with order and stability, and, being free from conscription, has not to depend upon the caprice of an imper- fectly educated proletariat for the preservation of her institutions. It is, therefore, fortunate for India to have her fortunes linked with those of the most sober and stable as well as one of the most advanced of the great nations of the day, although her own progress depends upon the influence that Britain and British genius can exercise upon the moral, intellectual, and economic life of her people, encrusted by several centuries of dormancy and decay. At present
THE BRITAINS 69
India is crushed between imperial democracy and democratic Toryism or separatist imperialism— the one too much occupied with the improvement of conditions at home to be able to devote atten- tion to distant parts of the Empire, and at the same time too afraid to apply Liberal principles to those parts for fear of losing the confidence of electors whose heads have been turned by the prospect of imperial sway and consequent afflu- ence ; the other, although inheriting the traditions of high breeding and culture, 3^et compelled by the circumstances of the day to profess to relin- quish the exclusive claim of a class to privilege, and, in order to secure popular support, to propagate the notion that its policy is dictated by the object of enabling the whole nation to play an " imperial " role over subject races. The vast majority of the nation have in the meantime to wait expectantly for the day when the support they render to the privileged order will be rewarded with happier conditions of their own existence, and have to be satisfied with seeing a few of their countrymen benefited by the imperial position they occupy in the world.
There are well-meaning progressives that advo- cate for India the system of popular government that has been developed in Britain through cen- turies of struggle in gradual process of evolution, though this system manifestly has still to undergo
70 ORIENT AND OCCIDENT
modification according to the needs of the changing times. There are others professing Liberal opinions in domestic British affairs that would Hke to see India under democratic govern- ment, but the democracy thej' would place in authority is not the Indian people but the Euro- pean democracy from which they themselves have sprung. There are Conservatives of the old school, although their ranks are being fast thinned by modern conditions, that would apply to India as to Britain and to the other parts of the Empire the same principles of just and benevolent govern- ment, but they claim that they and their class must exercise the main control. Others, who spring from the lower middle class, and for social reasons deem it politic to pass as Conservatives, are influenced by financial considerations to wish that India, and every other country whose policy can possibly be controlled, should have only such institutions as would enable them and their friends to achieve success in life. There are the extreme and unprincipled reactionaries that, find- ing their voice silenced and their occupation endangered by the aw^akening of the people at home, advocate in the name of patriotism and of order, of which they pose as champions, the per- petuation of tutelage in the backward parts of the world in order that reaction may still thrive somewhere among mankind.
THE BRITAINS 71
European barristers practising in India, or appearing in Indian lawsuits in the London courts, generally observe the distinctive tradition of their noble and learned profession by retaining an attitude of independence and impartiality to- wards the people of the country in which they live and practise. There may be " black sheep " in any flock, and in recent years a few such barristers have found it difficult to fill their bags with briefs or to secure judicial appointments without assailing, in and out of season, the Indian people in order to please those they serve— the planters and other non-official Europeans who, although but temporary residents, believe they have secured in India for themselves and their friends and relations the privileged position of the Orangemen in Ireland.
There are, however, thoughtful and disin- terested people, not pushful enough to make their voice heard, who think that, Britain's connection with India having come about, not by regular conquest but by the consent and help of the people, and, even if by conquest, for reasons of lasting good, it is most desirable and would be comparatively easy to place the relationship on a satisfactory footing without any appeal to force, coercion, or domination. It would probably have been so if the rule of the East India Company had been formally transferred to the Crown with-
72 ORIENT AND OCCIDENT
out the unfortunate incident of the Mutiny. While the Mutiny was the occasion of bringing India under the direct and open sway of the Government of Britain, the necessity of its sup- pression by force and the excesses reported to have been committed in its course, although the princes and the people generally sided with the Government, put a different complexion on the relationship. Before the Mutiny there used to be periodical inquiries by Parliament preliminary to each renewal of the Company's charter, and eminent Members as well as far-seeing statesmen kept a watchful eye over the interests of the help- less Indian people, and availed themselves of every opportunity to press reforms according to their ideas of justice. Since the transfer such inquiry has been declared to be impossible, as it would mean placing the administration on trial. Holders of power naturally consider existing con- ditions satisfactory, and will not touch them except under compulsion, while independent Members of Parliament are too much occupied with the demands of their constituents and with their private affairs to have time to study com- plicated Indian problems. Steam and electricity have brought India closer to Britain, with a corre- sponding increase in the number of European sojourners springing from classes that have now by enfranchising measures been given a voice
THE BRITAINS 73
in the government, and that with increasing affluence are apt to discourage or oppose changes that may possibly inure to their own disadvan- tage. Under the system that now prevails it is all but vain to expect progressive government and needed reforms. A hopeful beginning might be made if the Minister responsible for India were so convinced of their necessity as to threaten to resign unless he had his way (as would be the case in any other department of the State), and if strong men with reforming zeal and with energy enough personally to study the problem without dependence upon the guidance of subordinates cared to hold the position with a single eye to the public good. The Imperial Parliament, consider- ing the size of the Empire and the mass of ques- tions (home and foreign) with which it has to deal, will never have the time or the inclination to interfere with the policy pursued in distant parts of the Empire that have no direct voice in the election of Parliament and no control over its Members. The Press is now a powerful instru- ment in forming public opinion, but unless a subject is likely to be popular or profitable, journalists cannot be expected to take it up ; and, indeed, there are few in any generation that have the foresight and courage persistently to advocate a policy that they believe will vitally affect the future, when such policy does not catch the
74 ORIENT AND OCCIDENT
popular imagination of the day or is regarded by any considerable number of constituents and patrons as inimical to their interests.
The assumption by the British Crown of direct sovereignty, the proclamation issued to the princes and people of India by Queen Victoria on such assumption, and by King Edward and King George on their accession, the attachment to the Crown of a separate title relating to India, and the Royal visit to celebrate a Coronation Durbar— these are striking events that have brought the Sovereign into direct and close touch with the hearts of the people. Good government in every country depends upon the conscientious- ness as well as upon the dexterity of its rulers. How far such conscientiousness may in ordinary human nature be counted upon is evident from the fact that, although the British Government owes its existence to popular election at intervals of half a dozen years, and is composed of some of the best men in the country, yet the watchful eye of a strong Opposition is needed and has to be constantly exercised in every proposal of legis- lation and administration as a check on the Government. The Colonies have become prac- tically independent States, retaining connection with Britain mainly for safety from foreign invasion and conquest. If India is to have good and progressive administration, one of three
THE BRITAINS 75
courses for securing it seems to be necessary : (1) to have a standing Parliamentary Committee specially charged to keep watch and to advise the Government on all matters connected with Indian policy ; (2) to have rulers of India whose connection with the country will not cease as soon as they have secured a fortune or a pension ; (3) to invest the Crown with full rights of direct rule, with the assistance of an advisory council partially renewable every three or four years, and with a representative assembly without any voice in the constitution or the dismissal of the adminis- tration. A form of government approaching that of Germany or of Japan would suit present con- ditions ; but the first plan is most in accordance with present tendencies, and would bring without legislative change a vast improvement in govern- ment and administration. So long as none of these courses is adopted, India, however much she may contribute to secure fame or fortune to a number of people, will continue to be a part of the Empire the complexity of whose problems will make even men of light and leading shy of touching them, while all the time remaining the nursery of conceit and reactionary ideas for those that come in contact with her, and occasioning anxiety in regard to her capacity to resist foreign invasion. In the case of the Colonies such com- plexity disappears, and the Colonials have only
76 ORIENT AND OCCIDENT
to express a wish to have it realized : they have not to depend for its realization upon the self- denying benevolence of monopoly or of capital.
If Britain's connection with India continues to be what reaction so much desires— foreign rule over a conquered people, or what may be described as imperial separatism— its advantages and disadvantages will counterbalance each other. While on the one hand the intoxication produced by premature concessions will be avoided, on the other hand thoughtless and short-sighted obsti- nacy, mistaken for firm government, will increase self-complacency and retard progress. The advantages of self-government could be secured in a despotism if the rulers were adroit, patriotic, and unselfish, and proved to the people by acts as well as by words that they feel it to be their duty to advance the welfare of the country whose interests they have undertaken to serve. They have to recognize that it is too late to lament the effects produced by British teaching and example, the natural effects of the British connection — such lamentation only proving their degeneracy from the old British spirit and their untrustworthiness ; that it is possible for administrators to be able yet narrow-minded ; and that they have to guide education and administrative policy in such a manner as, without raising suspicion, to avoid the evil results of premature democracy, and at
THE BRITAINS 77
the same time to give effect to the British Liberal principle of respect for nationalism and of trust in the people. It is human to err or to appear to be unjust ; but, so long as the error or the injustice does not proceed from deliberate mischievousness, it will not be irremediable.
British education has caused a great revolution in the moral tone of the Indian people, as it has done in the people of Britain ; but it has been deficient in strengthening the feeling of reverence that was characteristic of Aryan teaching. That deficiency is due to the free spirit imparted by British teaching, in which fraternity combines with dutifulness to take the place of obedience ; but in the first stages the two often become dis- jointed. It should be observed by those subject to that teaching, however, that its purpose is not to increase self-love, from which to self-deception is but a step, but to train the mind to liberty going hand in hand with loyalty. On the other hand, British education and example have not, except in a few individual cases, produced any widespread desire for or sane ideas about urgent social reforms— as to child marriage, sanitation, pil- grimage to shrines, caste exclusiveness, and such matters, for which licence is claimed by bigots on the ground of their being based on religion, with which the Government rightly abstains from interference. British teaching has stimulated the
78 ORIENT AND OCCIDENT
reasoning faculty, which, however, owing to the neutraUty of authority, continues under the domination of tradition, superstition, and bigotry ; and men of light and leading, whether European or Indian, do not encourage change, as such encouragement would be a condemnation of the system that they have hitherto acquiesced in and supported.
It is a singular dispensation of Providence that two countries and races so differently constituted, so widely apart by distance, history, traditions, and worldly fortunes, should have been linked together by a union destined so strongly to influence both of them for good or for evil. When two human forces meet, one humble and the other proud, one observant and the other intoxicated, one receptive and the other self- sufficient, the advantage must in the long run lie with the more sober and gentle force. It is as in the relationship of a married couple : the husband may seem powerful and dominant, but the wife moulds his conduct and his destiny. In the connection between England and India the advantage could not but be on the side of the latter. Some persons who value gewgaws and unsubstantiality may deem what England gained by the connection something worth having — pres- tige and wealth. Among the short-sighted, the uncultured, and the mercenary these things are
THE BRITAINS 79
always of value, but in the eyes of the cultured and thoughtful both are often useless and some- times mischievous. Prestige is a deceptive thing, and without the support of solid elements it can- not long succeed ; while wealth, being a gift of the goddess that is proverbially fickle, appears, unless pretty equally divided in a community and endowed with stability, to cause as great evils as want : for, if want of competence in any large section leads to violence and revolution, super- fluous wealth leads its possessor to luxury and self-indulgence, which undermine manhood, life, and happiness.
English statesmen and other great Englishmen of the eighteentli and the first half of the nine- teenth century did not attach much value to the acquisition of dominion in India, and so they left the government in the hands of a corporation of traders, who on their part were so jealous of intruders that every foreigner wishing to try his fortune in India had to take out a pass, as Asiatics have now to do in some of the British Colonies. The only real gain to England— a gain that it is the ambition of every idealist to achieve — was that she was installed in a position to influence for good one-fifth of the human race, at that time in a state of decay, the different parts suffering from internecine feuds and jealousies, tyrannized by local authorities that had passed
80 ORIENT AND OCCIDENT
beyond the control of the central Government, and possessed of no organized party strong enough to form a Government capable of main- taining order within and of resisting aggression from outside. The leaders of the people welcomed the English as divine messengers sent to relieve them from oppression and to bring them peace and rest. How prophetic was their vision was proved by the succession of wise rulers and able soldiers sent out from England, who, by a career of administrative capacity and of conquest rivalled in recent times only by Napoleon, while unaccompanied by the weakness which caused his downfall, step by step brought all India under orderly government and laid the foundations of that policy of education and free- dom that had made the British race the greatest liberal force among mankind. Some of the modern successors of those great rulers and conquerors find fault with that policy because it has " awakened " the people of India — or certain classes and individuals, as it pleases them to say— and has made them clamorous for full British citizenship. They may as well blame those great Englishmen that, after a long struggle, secured education and enfranchisement for the toiling masses of their own countrymen, who have thus been enabled to develop their manhood and to render to their King and country service that
THE BRITAINS 81
would otherwise be restricted to a small class and a few families. The condemnation of the policy of education and freedom by men that would themselves not be educated or free if their rulers had not been liberal and wise— this is one of the most curious phases of modern life, and proves how the mind under evil influence is apt to forget itself and its antecedents.
The advance of democracy in Britain has pro- duced one notably undesirable feature. When a small class and a few families held power, their good manners and their concern for the welfare of the people of India, as well as for their own humbler countrymen, were proverbial. Nowa- days, whether the shortening of distance by steam and telegraph, colonial influence, and the frequent visits home are responsible for the apathy and even antipathy displayed by both the official and the trading classes in India, which King George (then Prince of Wales) lamented on his return from his Indian tour, or whether the keen struggle of existence at home takes men and women out before they have formed their character and have had opportunities of acquiring good breeding and British ways of life and thought, the men that are sympathetic or even outwardly polite are becoming so rare that, when an Englishman braves the prevailing atmosphere among his own countrymen, he is worshipped as
82 ORIENT AND OCCIDENT
a hero by the people of India, and receives pro- portionate condemnation from the reactionary camp in all parts of the Empire. Similarly those Indians that are found on the side of reaction or of the existing order are lauded as the true representatives of their race and country.
The present " imperial " idea is to regard the founders and consolidators of the British Empire as fools for having initiated a liberal policy in any part of the Empire. It may be " imperialism " to denounce the people for their faults, real or imaginary, but it is scarcely states- manship to avow incapacity to mend them. It may be " imperial " policy to try to stifle at their birth infant nationalities in difl'erent parts of the Empire, bound like the four parts of the United Kingdom ultimately to form a solid whole, but it is scarcely British to regard patriotism, although it may for want of proper guidance be erratic, as synonymous with disloyalty, sedition, and anarchism. That phase of the mind which at a certain stage of its development finds pleasure in being strong to the weak and deems it prudent to be weak to the strong is responsible for the sham imperialism which is ready to concede every demand of those parts of the Empire that are practically independent of Britain, yet tries to assert all its reactionary strength in India, which is in need of sympathetic guidance to
THE BRITAINS 83
fall into line with the progressive sections of the Empire and of mankind. The charge of sedition levelled against men that wish simply to have fair play and to participate in the rights of British citizenship can hardly be sincere in men whose ancestors attained freedom by successful rebellion against oppressive authority, and who themselves at the present day labour to vilify his Majesty's Government in order to oust it from power, and even threaten on behalf of a small minority in Ireland armed rebellion against authority should self-government be granted. In the British Empire (outside India) "anarchism" cannot be a crime, since (as Lady Dorothy Nevill records in her " Reminiscences ") Mr. Gladstone himself was re- garded by Conservatives as a " Satanic Anarchist." In self-government rulers may think or act as they like, since a wide-awake people would in case of incapacity or undutifulness soon relegate them to oblivion. True imperialism, like Rama in the Aryan epic, when he discarded his virtuous queen to conciliate his subjects, would lead its advocates to be even more anxious than when under popular control to encourage criticism and to make the most liberal concessions. Timely and adequate concession is one of the most diffi- cult problems of life. Too long delayed conces- sion fails to remove bitterness and grievances, while intoxicating power and rendering it un-
84 ORIENT AND OCCIDENT
generous ; premature or too ample concession generates pride and complacency in the people. The turn that the " imperial idea " has taken in Britain by its success in India is to proclaim the British people to be unfit for self-government, the House of Commons to be unqualified to legislate without control, and peers and their supporters to be the natural leaders of the people. It is often asserted by a certain class of minds that some races of men are made " imperial " by nature, and that some individuals in each race are born to rule. The one statement is incon- sistent with the other. If a race is made by nature imperial, every member of that race must be imperial too and equally able to rule. Those who in Britain profess to hold that the " British race is imperial " should be the first to admit that every Briton is a born ruler of men. If they were sincere in their conviction, they would not abuse the men in power, who are as much Britons as themselves, and laud a few families as alone gifted with the capacity to govern the Empire without election by the people. If capacity to govern is inherited there should be much more governing capacity in India than in any other country, since Aryans there organized a system of government and society long before the greater part of Europe emerged from barbarism.; and, if the germ of capacity and
THE BRITAINS 85
culture is retained in the blood, as is often stated in the case of successful men that have had a few great ancestors, that germ, dormant though it is bound to be after such a long sleep, ought to exist in every member of the higher castes in India. Theories are advanced and statements are made by people as suits their dispositions and momentary interests, and it is a matter of no consequence whether self-government or Crown- government prevails so long as the rulers are anxious to advance the interests of the people under their care.
The ideal at which all sane people in Britain, even in the privileged classes, had previously aimed, the ideal that must be steadily maintained in order to preserve British character and institu- tions from decay, is to extend British institutions and freedom as quickly as possible to every country after its conquest and annexation, as has been done in the Colonies by Liberal adminis- trators with such remarkable success. If that wise policy were sincerely, even though slowly, followed, and not permitted to degenerate into the hypocritical pretence of holding out hopes and disappointing in action, as in some quarters it is deemed shrewdness to do, the heart of every patriotic Briton would rejoice at the prospect of the political unity of the Empire and of the triumph of British principles. New India,
86 ORIENT AND OCCIDENT
although preserving all her sacred and time- honoured possessions, is a creation of British statesmanship of the days of old, the statesman- ship that held it a greater honour to mould graciously the destinies of fellow -men than to pose as divine and infallible, and that thought it nobler and more chivalrous to raise from the mire an ancient race and to lead it towards self- government than to let it slumber for the sake of momentary advantages. What statesmanship and sympathetic official leadership can do for ancient peoples possessing the germs of culture is shown by the remarkable rise of Japan and by the events that are taking place in China. India was awakened by British statesmanship while those countries were still in sleep. Now that they have commenced to show dazzling lights, the brood of blind self-seekers deem it advisable to send India to sleep again. It is difficult to believe that, at the instigation of this interested gang of con- spirators, whose chief weapon is appeal to prejudice, the authorities that speak in the name of England will be induced to divert British statesmanship from its traditional career of emancipation, and to attempt, as despotism has apparently done in Poland and Finland without strengthening itself, to smother an infant nationality at its first sign of awakening. Should the conspiracy succeed, the growth of the new
THE BRITAINS 87
nationality may be deferred, and India may at the instance of un-English Englishmen continue to be the moral and material plague-spot of man- kind, but she will not suffer alone. A chain cannot be strong so long as it has a weak link ; the British Empire cannot be invulnerable so long as India continues to inspire fear and does not become as strong as any other link in the great chain forged by Providence for the good of mankind.
Reverence for authority and love of order are inherent in human nature. In India and in the East generally, where the Sovereign is regarded as the vicegerent of God and as the embodiment of impartiality'^, justice, and righteousness, and where personal power asso- ciated with mercy is still worshipped, it is not difficult for rulers, speaking and acting in the name of the Sovereign and displaying some of his attributes, to evoke loyalty and devotion to the Throne. How much greater would be such loyalty and devotion if the Sovereign were known to be personally watching over the welfare of his subjects ! No more profoundly impressive sight has ever been presented in the streets of Calcutta than when hundreds of thousands of Hindus, headed by their leaders, marched with bare feet and in mourning garb, as in a funeral procession for a father or a mother, to express
88 ORIENT AND OCCIDENT
their loss at the demise of King Edward VII. In the royal progress through India in 1911-12 no scene was more thrilling than when King George, to the dismay of his entourage and of his body- guard, went among the crowd on the Maidan at Calcutta and made them wild with loyal delight.
A happy augury for the future, unique in British-Indian history, was the desire of King George and Queen Mary to proceed to India and to hold a Coronation ceremony. The presence and personal influence of the embodiments of sovereignty were bound to have a beneficial effect on the attitude of both rulers and ruled towards each other, to promote greater harmony among all classes, and to bring about a sense of the unity and solidarity of the Empire. The Coronation Durbar would have been beneficial if it did nothing else but demonstrate the King's anxiety for the welfare of his subjects there as elsewhere, the importance attached by the Sovereign and his advisers to that part of his dominions, and the " eternal " nature of the city that was selected as the scene of wha:t in ancient Hindu times was called the Rajasiiya Yagna — the celebration in the presence of sub- ordinate rulers of the assumption of supreme power by the Sovereign of the whole country.
The most potent hindrance to a happy relation- ship between England and India is the tendency
THE BRITAINS 89
of people to be swayed by the impulse to take up a cry or a sentiment expressed by a forward or outspoken comrade. The Colonials have claimed and been conceded generous treatment owing to a white skin making them " kith and kin," although human history does not show that jealousies and rivalries among kith and kin have been less fierce than among races and classes not connected by blood. Nor do the Colonials show any great consideration for the interests of the Mother Country to which they owe their existence and their security. The evil influence of the cry of " kith and kin " can be counter- acted only by action in the spirit of the declara- tion on the part of the Sovereign, proclaimed before the Colonies assumed such importance, that in his eyes all his subjects are alike and that one part of the Empire is as important as another. In India, as the Sovereign cannot be person- ally present to discharge the functions of the supreme ruler, the system of Viceroyalty was instituted. A Viceroy is sent out every five years in order that the head of the Government, who, like the Prime Minister at home, is responsible for policy, should carry into the administration of India a fresh English mind, free from preju- dices and prepossessions, and impartial to the needs and aspirations of all classes, creeds, and races. Having to deal with a subordinate staff,
90 ORIENT AND OCCIDENT
mainly composed of timid or lethargic Conserva- tives, and being unable to hear any Liberal sentiment, much less to receive support for Liberal tendencies, the Viceroy, even when a sturdy Liberal at home, becomes in a short time —generally within two years after arrival— the resigned tool of the cleverest of his Conserva- tive colleagues, and forgets that he is not, like the Prime Minister, a party or racial leader, but the representative of the majesty of the Crown. If he associates much with non-official Europeans, these manage to convince him of their importance as representing " British " interests which, like corresponding interests at home, are in need of special protection against popular demands. If he displays impartiality in any matter, he becomes the object of Anglo-Indian suspicion. If he tries to be liberal, generous, and English, like Lord William Bentinck, Lord Canning, or Lord Ripon, he gets nicknames like " Clemency Canning," and runs the risk of being insulted, or even kidnapped, an experi- ence with which, it is well known. Lord Ripon was threatened. How difficult it now is to satisfy the foreigners in India who, having tasted the blood of privilege, are always asking for more, is apparent from the attitude they assumed towards Lord Minto. In spite of his repressive measures and of " deportations " without trial,
THE BRITAINS 91
because he made some attempts to conciliate the people he was threatened, as a correspondent of a London Conservative organ wrote from Cal- cutta, with the same fate as Lord Ripon ! Re- actionary threats, after Lord Ripon's fate, prove efficacious in hindering reforms.
Whatever motive leads young people to go and seek their fortunes in India, the step involves a loss for Britain ; because, in the first place, owing to their inability to colonize or to stay long in the country, their energies are lost to their own country, or to a favourably placed land where they would not decay ; secondly, because, as there is no opening in India for the display of originality or exceptional cleverness, the opportunity for the development of virile faculties is lost ; and thirdly, because, after a long residence under a burning sun in the midst of pleasure, lethargy, and a meek and docile population, the temper is soured, the nature becomes conceited, British instincts are under- mined and gradually lost, and with the inevitable return home comes the appreciation of high- handed methods and the leaven of reaction, which threatens to enfeeble the love of freedom and fair play in Britain and to hand over her future to an oligarchy.
The temper of the party of privilege and monopoly with regard to India is apparent from
92 ORIENT AND OCCIDENT
the declaration of such a cultured and respon- sible person as the late leader of the Tory Party that India's position in the Empire precludes her from having a voice in the policy of Pro- tection. Thus even India's rulers are denied the right of doing what they believe to be good for her in matters affecting British interests — a denial not for a moment entertained in the case of the Colonies — while in matters affecting Indian interests alone they are given a free hand to do as they like without any control from home. According to this school, India is an opening for the sons and daughters of the educated im- pecunious classes — the sons being handicapped at home by increasing competition, the daughters finding the marriage market more and more closed owing to prevailing ideas of independence and thriftlessness — and an outlet for British capital. Even so, British capital will gain more by advance in the happiness and prosperity of the people, by feeding and nursing the goose than by cutting it open to extract all the golden eggs at once. In this controversy of Protec- tion against Free Trade it ought to be remem- bered that India is largely a self-contained country, like the United States and the British Colonies, and that her new industries (being in their infancy) and some old ones (defunct or dying) need encouragement. As labour is cheap,
THE BRITAINS 93
she ought to be able to produce at a cheaper cost price than foreign countries many articles she now imports. Guidance, sound methods, and co- operation, as well as capital, are needed ; and if Britain provides these, with humane treatment in other ways, India is not, like the Colonies, so ungrateful as to forget her benefactor or to do anything to injure his interests. Until, how- ever, India can produce all articles needed for her wants, her interest lies, like that of Britain, in Free Trade, so that raw material and manu- factured articles may not rise in cost by a tariff, and her products may not be subjected to duty in other countries.
The very fact of discriminating between the interests of the people of England and of the people of India, of opposing any administrative or legislative reform because it will benefit the one or injure the other, is a disruptive force that ought to be discouraged by far-sighted statesman- ship. The temper of " damn the consequences," enunciated by a recent addition to the peerage and adopted by the House of Lords in November, 1909, is not so harmful in Britain, where the electors can guard their own interests, as it is in India. That temper had led reactionaries con- nected with India to instigate the human mind to malice and uncharitableness, and to make a distinction in the matter of rights and duties
94 ORIENT AND OCCIDENT
between his Majesty's European and Indian sub- jects. If such distinction is to guide the policy of the Empire, it is vain to expect peace or goodwill among the different races and classes that combine to constitute the British Empire. It is a common occurrence in families for the children to fight with each other over trifles, to wish to monopolize any toy or sweet placed before them ; but if the parents or guardians favour some children and deny liberal treatment to others, the deprived children not only feel a grudge against their favoured sisters and brothers, but gradually come to dislike their parents as unkind and unjust. They cannot be expected when adolescent to stick to the parental house- hold, or to feel through life any great inclination to help each other in danger or difficulty, which is bound at times to crop up in human affairs.
The bold and courageous policy followed by the Government of Sir Henry Campbell-Banner- man towards South Africa, by granting it self- government five years after its conquest and annexation, and enabling the whilom commanders of the enemy's forces to be the first Ministers of the new British dominion, is not palatable to the average statesmanship, whose prominent charac- teristic is excessive caution and hesitation, with occasional expression of patronizing benevolence. To such statesmanship it seems safer to blunder
THE BRITAINS 96
with timidity, to retain the right to domineer over people that may be placed under its power, to continue the dominance of might over right, and to encourage the nursing of the feeling of revenge, than to be courageous with generosity, to extend the hand of cordial fellowship, which might under conceivable circumstances be mis- understood and might possibly not leave a feeling of gratitude behind. An attitude of confidence and respect towards a vanquished foe, or towards people who would be foes but for such confi- dence, is the essence of the ideal relationship, between man and man. It has always been dis- played by great heroes that have left their mark in history, but it cannot be expected of every politician that may happen to gain prominence in a State, and whose humane and progressive ideas and strength of conviction may lack the courage to brave the ridicule of petty minds and to run the risk of failure. It is possible to con- ceive that a great leader will at the proper time arise in England to do for India what the Govern- ment of Sir Henry Campbell -Bannerman did for the conquered Boer States and what the Government of Mr. Asquith proposes to do for Ireland. The chief difficulty lies in the fact that, while in the case of the Boers no traditions had to be sacrificed and no bureaucracy had to be conciliated— no time being given for their
96 ORIENT AND OCCIDENT
existence— and in the case of Ireland 85 votes in the House of Commons have considerable influ- ence on policy, in the case of India 150 years of bureaucratic traditions, monopolies, and vested interests, combined with absence of Indian voice in Parliament, stand like an impregnable bulwark, which a masterly stroke by an exceptional giant can alone carry by assault.
The issue that divides India from the rest of the Empire is whether she is to continue outside British Dominions while remaining a field for exploitation by natives of those Dominions, or whether her aspiration to be included in those dominions is to be satisfied, so that she may become as strong a link in the chain of Empire as any other Dominion. If, because the people are of a different religion or complexion, India is to be of the Empire but not in it — in other words, if she is to remain a mere dependency — and if her people are to continue to be treated, not as human beings, but as worse than cattle in human form (cattle being cared for by societies), it seems unreasonable to expect from them such hearty loyalty to the connection with Britain as can be conciliated only from an atti- tude of fairness and goodwill. The position of British Indians at the present time is peculiar. In foreign States and by international law they are of British nationality, but within the Empire
THE BRITAINS 97
they are neither British nor alien, and are de- barred from serving their Sovereign and Empire in many of the important spheres open to their fellow-subjects of other parts of the Empire. The weak or reactionary brain may demur to the policy of fair play and goodwill, because it cannot conceive a state of affairs in which all classes and races within the Empire should have equal legal rights and equal opportunities of distinc- tion and of service to the State. Monopoly and privilege are what the " imperialist " under- stands best and would like to perpetuate, until the complete demoralization of the privileged order itself by the intoxication of irresponsible power and the degradation of the rest to a state of servitude, or until civil war and a resulting foreign invasion and conquest, cause his efface- ment. Consistency is a virtue that cannot be expected of the " imperialist " brain, otherwise it may be asked why in Britain monopoly of patriotism and power is claimed by the land- owners, while in India it is claimed by and for those that have no such stake in the country and are a constantly changing body.
It is impossible for despotism and freedom to flourish side by side within a State without pro- ducing unfortunate results. If it were possible to exterminate the whole population of India, as the aborigines in some of the Colonies have been
8
98 ORIENT AND OCCIDENT
extirpated, peace and progress might ensue, and India might conceivably in course of time come to be in the position of the other daughter States with self-governing institutions, and not be a source of weakness and danger to the Empire. As matters stand, she not only lays Britain open to the taunt of hypocrisy and inconsistency in ad- vocating freedom and liberal institutions in foreign countries, in standing as the champion of oppressed nationalities struggling to be free, while following a different policy within the Empire, but also communicates to Britain, through those retiring after service in India or returning from a visit to India, the reactionary ideas they imbibe during their stay. If a reac- tionary policy is successful in India, their minds get accustomed to it, and they naturally conclude that it should be equally useful to Britain ; while, if it is not successful, a patriotic impulse prevents them from condemning the acts of their country men, acquaintances, and friends, and such con- donement of wrong weakens principles and degrades the mind. Thus evil is perpetuated ; Britain gets more and more leavened by reaction imported from India ; and it looks as if even English Liberalism might soon sink to a pious tradition antiquated by the glory of imperial sway, in which a few families and a small class will again play in Britain the parts which a handful
THE BRITAINS 99
of men find so captivating and dazzling in India.
How matters have drifted may be gauged from the Press, in which a few years ago a considerate spirit towards India, such as is now displayed towards the Colonies, generally prevailed, whereas now but few even of the journals that are Liberal in other matters can refer to India and Indians otherwise than in tones of super- cilious contempt. India will not suffer alone by the encouragement of the tendency, as is evident from the language often used towards political opponents in Britain by the class claim- ing a monopoly of good breeding. The respon- sible leaders of the Tory party have already put into plain words the firm belief of the peers that the Liberals have no right to be in power at all, that even when they are in office the Tories ought to rule, and that the only proper advisers of the Sovereign are the Conservatives— roughly, the holders of land, the possessors of wealth, and their supporters — whom the toiling classes by a vote of confidence every six or seven years are to maintain in office until, as in autocratically governed countries, the vote of electors becomes of no consequence, and ministers remain in power at the will of the Peers. Until, however, these opinions come to be generally held in Britain, when the choice will lie between oligai'chy and
100 ORIENT AND OCCIDENT
revolution, no reasonable man would argue that the Sovereign should proscribe his Indian sub- jects as advisers on the needs of his government in India or as defenders of his throne and power. The struggle that has in recent years been initiated in India by the British connection is not between " British rule " and any other rule ; it is not between British and Indian interests ; nor is it to subvert the Government, as enemies of conciliation and of human advancement would fain lead people to believe, in order to have the brutal satisfaction of tyrannizing over rivals or victims that are in their power ; it is the perennial struggle between reaction and progress, between monopoly and justice, between despotism and freedom. As the permanent victory of the Peers in the constitutional conflict brought on by their rejection of the Budget of 1909 would have meant the destruction of self-government in Britain, the continuance of race domination in India tends to carry with it, what reactionaries so much desire, the discomfiture of Liberalism within the Empire, the effects of which must inevitably be far-reaching, affecting the heart as well. If Indians are to remain the pariahs of the outskirts of the Empire, if birth in a particular circle or locality is to be the passport to service to the State, the real British people will be the descendants of the Norman conquerors
THE BRITAINS 101
and their relations and henchmen ; the others will be the outcasts, whose self-government will consist in recording an occasional vote for their rulers.
The interests of Britain and of India, and for that matter of all other countries and races with which Britain or India may be brought into close contact, are identical : what is good or bad for one cannot but have the same effect on the other. An idea has sprung up, mostly in " imperialist " circles, that India is being Westernized by English education, and that such education should be either stopped or modified. No greater want of the faculty of observation has ever been dis- played by man. It is easy to note signs that prove that England has been more Easternized by the connection with Asia than India has been Westernized. India has certainly been brought into contact with modern Western thought, and has been inspired by the modern Western ideas of progress and of nationalism— ideas that carry into practical life the Aryan conception of spiritual brotherhood, the corner-stone of which is sacrifice of self for the general good, because self is by education felt to be only a part of the whole. The " imperialist," who found extant in Asia the political conditions which after long struggle and much bloodshed have disappeared in Europe, and which it gladdens his heart to
102 ORIENT AND OCCIDENT
call " Oriental " because they assure the irre- sponsible domination of a few over the rest, naturally wishes to perpetuate these conditions in Asia and to bring them back to Europe. When two dissimilar forces come in contact, unless one is quickly overcome and destroyed, each is bound to exercise some influence over the other. The influence is not less if there is contempt, hatred, or indifference than when love and sympathy exist. One may brutalize and the other humanize, one may harden and the other soften the heart, but which is more potent in moulding life and conduct can be known only to each person exposed to such influence, or to impartial observers of the behaviour and ten- dencies of such person. The influence of Europe and Asia on each other is manifest in every country on both continents, and both are being brought nearer in ideas, each communicating to the other at the initial stages what may appear to be more evil than good, because in nature good is more difficult to communicate and to absorb than evil. The inevitable result of the contact cannot be evaded, although there are many persons in India who, exasperated by European bad manners, wish to boycott every- thing European, as there are persons in Europe who, instigated by Colonial example and prejudice or resenting the foolish acts of some undesirable
THE BRITAINS 103
Asiatics, despise everything Asiatic, while imbib- ing all the time Asiatic ideas and thriving on Asiatic gold and jewels.
How the contact with Asia has undermined the virility of Europe is evident from the fact that it is so difficult to find in European public life any expression of sympathy for, or encouragement of, the aspirations of Asiatic peoples, apparently because selfishness prompts that such sympathy does not pay. After a long sleep, induced by the same accession of self-complacency as seems to be taking possession of Europe, Asia is showing signs of waking up and of taking her place among the prominent forces of human progress. Those at any rate who profess progressive principles might have been expected to hel'p actively the attempt of Asia to be a progressive force. But, as in the decaying days of Asia the best class of minds, seeing the triumph of selfishness, pre- ferred an obscure and secluded life to association with the forces of evil, so the best minds of Europe, seeing the futility of trying to stem the rising tide of selfish greed and not liking to be called unpatriotic, seem to be relapsing into silence and letting the vultures have their way. A feeble voice here and there is occasionally heard, but it is drowned by the deafening din of self masquerading in the garb of patriotism. This din of democratic imperialism is preaching the
104 ORIENT AND OCCIDENT
new gospel of patriotism, which is to keep others in darkness in order that some may enjoy light, and to sacrifice eternal principles at the altar of momentary selfish gain— a curious patriotism that imitates the burglar and murderer when he has the victim in his grasp. Europe would run the risk of succumbing to selfishness and of declining as Asia declined owing to the selfish- ness of her ruling classes ; but Asiatic nations went down because for centuries no rival powers threatened them. The safety of European nations lies in the presence of rivals all on the alert, each awaiting a suitable opportunity for flying at another's throat. So long as this rivalry con- tinues and every nation is threatened with sub- jection or extinction if it goes to sleep, virile energies, although drawn away from more peace- ful pursuits, will be kept alive for the preservation of life.
The danger of following in India a policy different from the traditional British policy of freedom and fair play — a policy recalling measures deemed necessary in the days of counter-revolutionary terror under Castlereagh and Eldon— is that " British rule " would, in the estimation of the people, be brought down to a lower level than the autocratic rule prevailing in Russia, Germany, and some other continental States. In those countries the system of Govern-
THE BRITAINS 106
ment, although autocratic, is national, and is based on the notion that a change from militarism would endanger the safety of the State, and that popular government would undermine its strength and facilitate foreign invasion and subjection. The struggle of mass against class is more acute in these States than in Britain, but there can be no racial oppression. Cases of individual oppres- sion no doubt happen at times, but, being devoid of racial prejudice or privilege, as should be the case in India, the wrong-doers meet with punish- ment. In India, punishment of a public servant abusing his authority, or even of a criminal European, is considered injudicious as likely to weaken prestige and to undo the reign of terror on which order is believed to rest. The capacity or the disposition to regard both sides of a ques- tion is rare, and the view to which people are accustomed is naturally given greater promi- nence ; but absolute power must be singularly destructive of the reasoning faculty if it leads to the conclusion that authority commands more fear and respect when its holders or its professing partisans can commit wrong with impunity.
Many well-intentioned people in Britain wish India to be outside Party politics. To be outside Party would mean for India worse than the cold shade of neglect : for if it is no Party's duty to champion the cause of any part of the Empire,
106 ORIENT AND OCCIDENT
that part must be made over to Satan, or retained, like a convict settlement, for the breeding of " imperial " ideas. It is a plausible dodge of triumphant reaction to hoodwink the progressive forces, and it too often succeeds when Liberal Governments hold office. How far India is from being out of Party is evident when Liberal Ministers are, in matters relating to India, more anxious to conciliate the Opposition than to satisfy their own supporters. The end of it all is that, although Britain may get at times a Liberal administration that tries to advance the welfare of the masses, India is almost always under the control of Conservatives, to whom any proposal of change, unless it be to make their power stronger, is scarcely less than sacrilege. The Government is called British when the object is to give Europeans the best posts in it, but it becomes Indian (or Asiatic) when an excuse for not applying European principles of administra- tion has to be found, or when financial liabilities have to be incurred. Similarly, in administration when efficiency is praised the credit goes to the European staff, and when any fault is found the censure falls to the lot of the hard-working and ill -paid Indian subordinates. This spirit of racial antagonism must be subversive of impartiality and efficiency in the administration and of loyalty in the Indian staff. The policy of fat pay, ease,
THE BRITAINS 107
perquisites, and praise as the share of the Euro- pean officers, and hard work and blame as that of the Indian rank and file, may be lauded to the skies by reaction— but scarcely by sensible persons— as ideal statesmanship.
The threat of Colonial secession hangs like the sword of Damocles over every British Govern- ment. Hence no demand made by the Colonies is considered too unreasonable or impolitic to con- cede. People profess great jubilation and profuse gratitude when a colony offers to construct one or more Dreadnoughts, manned by its own sons, and to lend them to Britain, not without con- sideration, but in return for participation in the Cabinet discussions on Imperial Defence and on Foreign Policy. On these terms even Germany, whom everybody is so anxious to conciliate, would, if properly approached, perhaps agree to lend to the British Government, in case of need, some of her own warships. India contributes annually nearly a third of her revenue towards the defence of the Empire, and sends her troops to whatever part of the world they are required to fight in, and yet, if the slightest concession to popular sentiment is asked by or for India — not to speak of a voice in Imperial policy — reac- tionary forces in Britain at once assert their full strength, to which even advocates of progress succumb, and all hold up their hands in horror
108 ORIENT AND OCCIDENT
for the safety of the Empire. It is no wonder that under these conditions the strongest Liberal minister cannot do much during his tenure of office, and India is left to drift to her doom. The history of mankind shows that, wherever and whenever the conflict between progress and reac- tion has become slack, decay and ruin have set in.
In one matter the Colonials receive, even at the hands of the party that profess undying love for them, scant consideration, and this, unless remedied, will interfere with the development of their ardent loyalty to the Empire. While the titles of Raja (king) and Maharaja (great king) are showered upon private British Indian citizens, and Indian Chiefs receive also salutes of guns as if they were independent Princes, the democratic Colonial appetite for titles and honours is but sparingly satisfied, as if through dread that its satisfaction would enable Colonials to intermarry with the British nobility. It is a slur on Colonial honour and antecedents to deem Colonials unfit to be placed on social equality with the Peers of the realm.
The latest policy enunciated by the present Colonial leader of Opposition is that when and if the Tory Party attain office the Colonies, and not the British people, will be afforded the opportunity of deciding the sort of commercial preference they desire and the amount of taxes
THE BRITAINS 109
the British people are to pay on their food. This is bending the knee at Colonial altars ; it is quite the other pole to the policy that lost Britain her great American colonies. If sanc- tioned by the voters at the next (or any other) General Election, the new policy will probably have the same result, though in the opposite way to the other : it will make the British people anxious to cast off the " Colonial millstones round our necks."
Not all Europeans are spoilt by the conditions of life in India, so different from what they are accustomed to at home. Those that are blessed with the spirit of toleration, those that are able to retain their balance of mind in spite of un- accustomed adulation and of the possession of unwonted luxuries in the shape of hosts of servants, carriages, and honours, and those that refrain from applying strong drinks as an antidote to the effects of grilling heat— these get acclima- tized to Indian conditions, come to like India and its people, and are even sorry to return home when they cannot at an advanced age revert to the conditions from which they have been separated during the best part of their lives. It is the men and women whose balance of judgment is upset that aspire, on the strength of difference of race or complexion, to play an imperial role, and that pretend that the safety of " British "
110 ORIENT AND OCCIDENT
rule depends upon the recognition of their claim to infallibility and inviolability. It is these that cause the growing estrangement between Asia and Europe, and are sowing the seeds of disruption of the Empire.
A potent cause of the " unrest," or dissatisfac- tion with the Government, has been the mis- carriage of justice in cases where an Indian has been brutally done to death by a European. This generally happens when an employer, after per- haps imbibing a drop too much of liquor, finds some fault with his servant, who, if he is so stupid as to face his master and not to run away, receives blows and kicks which " enlarge his spleen" and end his earthly career in a few minutes, hours, or days, according to the vigour with which they are administered. Indian servants get high wages from foreign masters, higher than from their own well-to-do country- men, and, in addition, are supposed to be able, like the same type in Europe, to bamboozle foreigners to their hearts' content ; hence, in spite of kicks and blows and tragic ends, the foreigners find no difficulty in getting servants. Neither better-caste Hindus nor Bengalis of any caste would serve foreigners in any menial capacity ; but the low-class Hindu and Moslem are always available, and these may, by their timid and unintelligent ways, perhaps rouse the
THE BRITAINS 111
foreigner's ire. Beating of servants is so common in European society outside Presidency towns that an employer that has been an exception to the rule is sometimes heard to brag that he has never thrashed his servants. The thrashing is indirectly, encouraged by the judiciary and local police, who, on account either of backstairs influence or of fear of incurring the displeasure of superiors, let a culprit escape justice, except in very grave cases that cannot be hushed up, and even then the murderer is generally let off with a fine of twenty or thirty rupees (£1 5s. to £2), because European juries, composed of clerks and shop- assistants, cannot be persuaded to convict of grave offence a member of their " own race." It is, as a London paper once remarked, " cheap homi- cide." It is doubtless cheap for the criminal ; but it is far from cheap for the Government, for every such case undermines its authority and prestige and shakes the popular faith in its capacity to protect its subjects. By law the Government has power to appeal against acquittals or inadequate punishment to the High Court, and when this power is exercised in the more advanced provinces a conviction with a term of imprison- ment generally satisfies the claims of justice. In these cases the poor witnesses, being of the class to which the victim belongs, are so browbeaten and frightened when giving evidence that they
112 ORIENT AND OCCIDENT
often contradict themselves in details. Such con- tradiction is made the excuse for acquittal or for a nominal punishment when a European is the offender ; but on much flimsier evidence Indians charged with similar offences are severely punished or sent to the gallows. Similar things happen when outrages on women take place on railways and in plantations. Common assaults on and insult to travellers and others by " imperial " or drunken foreigners, and even by foreign policemen, are of such frequent occur- rence that people have come to regard them as inevitable when they stir from home.
It is not unusual to find in every community, class, and race members that are disposed to wickedness and crime, so as to bring discredit on the whole body. In a well organized and dis- ciplined body such members are excommunicated, with deserved punishment. There is as much wisdom in condemning a community because a few are wicked as in spotting a few of the best men in it and calling it an angelic body, or in ignoring crime when committed by one's friends or relations. The moral atmosphere of a com- munity may be imagined when crime and wicked- ness are not only not condemned but positively condoned by the ,general body as prerogatives of a superior civilization. Such condonation has the threefold disadvantage of demoralizing the
THE BRITAINS 113
community itself, of degrading it in the estima- tion of other communities, and of setting a bad example to inferior classes and races by leading them to think that impunity for wickedness is a privilege and a sign of superiority. When a community encourages crime and harbours criminals it injures itself more than others ; and nobody need complain of the freedom claimed by individuals and classes to do what they like, so long as no injury is caused or bad example is set to others. The example of crimi- nality is stronger than the teaching of virtue, and people that do not themselves possess angelic virtues ought to be the last to find fault with the weaknesses of others. Assaults and insults, even murders and outrages, when com- mitted by foreigners on Indians, are not deemed worthy of notice in the columns of " imperialist " newspapers in Britain or in India, or, if noticed, they are minimized, whereas any offence com- mitted by an Indian is magnified and distorted to serve the purposes of " imperial " ascendency. This, according to Occidental natures, may be fair in political warfare ; but, as the Indian masses, for whose welfare the reactionaries pro- fess so much concern, are not yet cognizant of enlightened European methods of dealing with opponents, they take a primitive view of such matters, and regard the silence in one case and
9
114 ORIENT AND OCCIDENT
the distortion in the other as proceeding from an innate love of untruth and of wickedness.
A few cases may serve to illustrate the state of affairs.
In the first week of February, 1911, a Moham- medan member of the Viceroy's Council was travelling in the only first-class compartment of a train. A European military officer, joining the train, felt himself too exalted to travel with a " native," and asked the Indian gentleman to leave the compartment. On his hesitating to move as there was no other first-class carriage, the officer forced him, by the threat of using his sword, to get out and to go into a second-class carriage. The Anglo-Indian papers did not report the promotion, usual in such cases, gained by this officer for his " imperial " attitude towards an Indian gentleman. This is by no means an isolated instance. There is scarcely an Indian judge, Raja, or Councillor (not to speak of humbler mortals) that has not had, when travel- ling by rail, similar experience of this rude imperialism. In answer to a question in the House of Commons in April, 1911, the Under- Secretary for India stated a case in which a Mohammedan Councillor had left his servant in charge of his luggage in a first-class compart- ment while he was in the restaurant-car. A European sub -engineer of the railway turned the
THE BRITAINS 115
servant out, and forced him to travel to the next station (43 minutes) on the footboard. It was stated that the " imperial " engineer was made to " apologize " to the Mohammedan Councillor, but it was not stated whether the apology was tendered in the presence of the servant, who was arrested by the police for breach of railway regulations by travelling on the footboard and for failing to commit suicide. The engineer doubtless became a hero in his community and received promotion for his " imperial " bearing. The treatment of third- class passengers by the lower type of Europeans, as well as by the railway servants generally, may be imagined.
One would have thought that after the benefi- cent influence produced by the Royal visit cases of assault at railway-stations on Indian gentle- men would be unknown. In January, 1913, a case is reported to have been heard in the second magistrate's court at Bombay, in which an I. M.S. was charged with pushing and insulting at the Grant Road station a Hindu gentleman, who with his wife wished to get into a first-class compart- ment next to the one in which the I. M.S. was travelling. Hitherto " high-born " personages in East and West have objected to travel with smaller fry in the same compartment, but matters are advancing fast, and humble individuals must
116 ORIENT AND OCCIDENT
not wish to travel in the same train with the " imperial " breed. In this case the Hindu gentleman happened to be an ex-sheriff of Bom- bay. Although, being an athlete, he was strong enough to knock his assailant down, he preferred to lay a charge, at the hearing of which the. culprit was let off with an apology. One may imagine what would have happened if the posi- tion of the parties had been reversed. Europeans of the type of the I. M.S. are better recruiting- sergeants for the extreme Nationalist Party than " seditious " preachers and writers, and yet the authorities proclaim their helplessness to control them or to protect the people under their care. While Europeans in India indulge in these pranks, Indian gentlemen, however exalted their rank, receive grudging obedience from their servants and scant courtesy from policemen and subordinate officials, who regard every, European " tag-rag " as a greater personage than even Rajas and Nawabs. At the racecourse at Calcutta the writer once witnessed the Chief of a Tributary State — an honoured guest at the King's Coronation — refused admission to the pad- dock by the European policeman at the entrance — probably because he was dressed in ordinary, Indian costume, while every foreigner was being admitted without showing a ticket. A steward, luckily seeing from a distance the Maharaja
THE BRITAINS 117
turned away, rushed to the spot and took him in. These unfortunate incidents are more fre- quent on railways, and the authorities, instead of punishing the offenders, seem by their inaction and by the approbation of the foreign Press to encourage rudeness in the same way as Colonial harsh treatment of Indians is condoned by the Imperial Government. It is a strange nemesis that so many Moslem gentlemen have recently experienced such rudeness, as if to prove to Moslems generally the falsity of the anxiety of reactionary officialdom to conciliate them at the expense of Hindus. Perhaps the " apology " is tendered when the offended party is Moslem, while no notice would be taken of insult to a Hindu. Reaction would display greater wisdom if it were to issue private instructions to the " imperial " breed to display their " high-born " manners towards Hindus alone and to conciliate Moslems at every opportunity. So long as this attitude continues, Indian Nationalism has a sub- stantial ground for its propaganda, and with increasing strength its cry will grow louder that the only security against foreign outrage is to deport the offender. There are people in Britain who object to travel in the same railway com- partment with their humbler fellow-countrymen not so well groomed as themselves, and who object to go up in lifts with servants or postmen.
118 ORIENT AND OCCIDENT
Similarly there are foreign residents in India who object to travel with Indians, although some of the latter so objected to are wealthy enough to employ the former in service, and are person- ally much cleaner, much more sober and genteel, than the objectors to free travel. They do not object to live in the same town or country with the " natives," nor to pass along the streets and other public places with humbler folk, nor to breathe the air and to eat the food into which the wind has brought the dust from the road on which those " natives " tread. There must always be in every part of the Empire a few superior persons of this class, who seize every opportunity of prov- ing the nature of the stuff of which they are made. This sort of exclusiveness does no harm in India because the people objected to would like nothing better than to be left alone where no intruding, unclean, and unmannerly foreigner may disturb their peace. The mischief arises when a compartment already occupied by the " outcast of the Empire " is sought by a foreign " princeling " ; the occupants are turned out by force, or the female passengers are insulted, and no authority intervenes to stop or to punish the outrage. The railway officials, when they are Indians, on being appealed to, declare their powerlessness to interfere with European travel- lers who may break the law ; and European
THE BRITAINS 119
railway employees, unless exceptionally strict or fresh importations, generally refuse to enter- tain complaints against fellow-continentals, who must be above the law, or, having the ear of authority, may bring them into trouble. Matters in India have not yet come to the pass described in a book reviewed in a London Liberal journal in July, 1910, where it is stated that in parts of the United States, when a " white " man takes a dislike to a negro and shoots him dead, a false charge against the negro of attempting to kill him is pleaded as his excuse ; that such charge is certified by other " white " men that were never near the place of outrage ; and that on such evidence the murderer is acquitted, and the judge comes down from the bench to con- gratulate the accused and to express regret for putting him on trial. In India, the people being meek and disarmed, the excuse of threatened assassination or outrage is not available ; but pretexts for assaults are often found and the criminal goes scot-free.
Impartial justice is of prime importance in advancing contentment and national well-being. In the Britains of the West no judge or magis- trate would remain long in office if he did not hold the scales of justice evenly between one individual and another, however high or low the position in society of each might be. In India,,
120 ORIENT AND OCCIDENT
when a Liberal Viceroy wished to equalize the powers of judges and magistrates without distinc- tion of race, a howl was successfully raised by those that occupy in India the position of " peers of the realm " objecting to such equalization, on the ground that a peer cannot be tried by, an Indian commoner, but really because they thought that a " lordly " culprit would not have the same chance of escape that he has hithertO; enjoyed. After that experience no Government would again venture to introduce changes in the law that might secure impartial justice in criminal cases where Europeans are accused of offences against Indians. It may be politic that a " peer " should be tried by his peers — such privilege would relieve Indian judges of consider- able anxiety and worry — but to secure justice a commoner should in fairness be tried by his peers alone ; and to cast a slur on his Majesty's judges and magistrates because they are of a certain race or nationali-ty is scarcely the way to secure respect for law and justice, or to make that class of public servants devoted and con- tented. If any judge—" peer " or commoner — is habitually guilty of partiality or injustice, he should be removed, but so long as he remains a judge he should represent the majesty of the Crown. As a matter of fact, one never hears of the removal of a " peer " judge who dispenses
THE BRITAINS 121
injustice — as civilian judges and weak barrister judges selected in India for social reasons gene- rally do — and whose judgments are upset by the High Court on appeal, but Indian judges have been known to incur displeasure in high quarters for expressing opinions unpalatable to the " peers." It is said that a judge or magis- trate condemned by the High Court is generally promoted. A commoner or Indian judge that did not please the authorities that appointed him would not long continue to dispense justice. Judges, magistrates, or other officers of Govern- ment when they act foolishly against public interests should be as easily removable from their posts as chiefs are deposed when they incur the displeasure of the residents at their Courts. Jury trial is still confined to Presidency towns and certain districts with restrictions, but it has been so manipulated and made so different from the British system of " Trial by Jury " that in cases where a conviction is deemed necessary a jury is empanelled which is sure to convict— a majority deciding the issue, while in case of acquittal by a majority the judge may accept or reject the verdict at his option. Recently secret trials have been introduced, in which evidence is taken against an accused person without his presence.
Indians are being prosecuted and imprisoned
122 ORIENT AND OCCIDENT
for trying to " bring the Government into con- tempt " by their criticism of the acts of some of its servants ; but the foreigners who by their manners are bringing the European races into contempt, and the officials who by their partiality are the prime cause of bringing the Government into contempt, are granted free scope for the play of their evil instincts. Instead of trying to make the European more polite and humane, the re- actionaries instigate the punishment of the aggrieved. It is well known to scientists and other observers how even ants and worms when hurt try to bite or sting, and it is strange that human beings should be expected not to resent ill- treatment. To discourage such resentment, the reactionary device is, not to avoid treading on a worm, but to crush it. To crush three hundred millions of human worms is no joke even for the modern almighty " imperialist." If they could be crushed out of existence, the opportunities for the development of imperialist conceit would be considerably decreased.
The average European Briton is said to be able to stand any amount of rudeness at the hands of " my lord," so he naturally thinks that, being himself " my lord " in Asia, his bad manners will be equally palatable to the Asiatic. Circumstances being different, Asiatics do not quite appreciate " lordly " behaviour, and they cannot be justly
THE BRITAINS 123
expected to feel honoured by such behaviour when they see no patriotic services rendered among them by " my lords," such as the lords render to their own country. Army men, too, show contempt enough for mere civilians at home, but, being unable (as under continental military despotism) to wield irresponsible power, have to be content with fretting and fuming and swell- ing the ranks of the reactionary party. In India they are said to be more contemptuous of the " natives " who, although fellow-subjects, are not " brother-officers," and with the better classes of whom they never come in contact. Navy men must be still more haughty, because, while Indian Christians and Eurasians with dark skins are admitted into the volunteer ranks of the land forces, no dark-skinned man is enrolled among the naval volunteers. Thus army and navy men, who have not the opportunity that their civilian brethren possess of making the acquaintance of Indian gentlemen and ladies, become self-com- placent ; and, being convinced that the safety of the Empire rests with them, become instruments in widening the breach between the European and Indian Britons, and thus weakening the State of which they are the defenders.
The welfare of civilized communities is based on mutual respect between the rulers and the ruled. What respect the present rulers of India
124 ORIENT AND OCCIDENT
have for the people is indicated by the following administrative procedure. The finger-print system prevailing in some countries for the identification of criminals was introduced into a province even in civil life by its then reactionary Governor, who appears to have taken everybody to be a potential criminal, and it has since been extended to the whole of India. In registering any document, the executant, whatever his position in life may be, if unknown to the Registrar, although identi- fied by somebody known personally to him, has to dip his thumb in thick ink and impress it on the document in addition to his signature. A European, however, although he be unknown to the Registrar and have no one but his flunkey, a stranger to the Registrar, accompanying him, is not required to press his thumb in ink. The reason is said to be this : that, when the system was first introduced and applied to Europeans, a European asked for a washbasin to wash his thumb, and, on being told that the Government did not provide such a thing, wanted to wipe his thumb on the Registrar's white chudder. The real reason, of course, is that while the authorities did not venture to impose upon Europeans a method of identification suitable for criminals, they did not deem it too degrading for the people whose destinies were in their hands. Another governor laid down a rule that Indians of what-
THE BRITAINS 125
ever position in life and for whatever purpose leaving India for foreign countries would have to get a certificate of fitness from the " coolie " emigration agent— the governors evidently deem- ing it a great honour and celestial statesmanship to drag all the people under their sway down to the level of coolies. Is there any other country on the face of the globe where the officials think so meanly of the people whose interests are in their charge? And should they complain if the feeling is beginning to be reciprocated?
Aryanland flourished so long as caste, which originated with hereditary occupations, did not become stereotyped so as to make it impossible for a member of one caste to get into another by change of occupation, business, or knowledge, and thus to engender caste animosity. The safety of modern Britain lies in the welcome given to persons of humble birth when by, service to the State, intellectual attainments, or acquisition of wealth, they are raised by Royal favour to the highest grades of society. The decline and down- fall of Ancient India commenced when caste rules became rigid, when the caste of priests succeeded in monopolizing learning and in degrading the warrior caste, and when the Brahman was so consumed by conceit as to imagine himself equal to the " gods " and to look down upon the other castes with contempt. Wh,ile great Englishmen
126 ORIENT AND OCCIDENT
of days gone by proclaimed and followed a policy of humanity and justice throughout the British dominions, the self-governing ungovernables of the dominions beyond the seas have in recent times been permitted to revolutionize British notions by a claim to white-skinned divinity, with the result that there has been set up an invidious distinction of continent and of complexion as the basis of political rights and social justice, which has commenced to lead even the hitherto down- trodden masses of Europe to succumb to the weakness of looking down with contempt upon every product of Asia— except its gold. It seems to be but a question of time when Europe will be induced by its colonies to renounce Chris- tianity because it came from Asia.
A generation since, bad manners towards Asiatics were unknown or rare in Britain, except among some gutter-boys in London streets. Pig- ment prejudice against the " yellow " race seems to be disappearing among the better -class Euro- peans, perhaps owing to its display of martial and patriotic virtues ; but among other classes such bad manners are rampant in all parts of the country. The only means of stopping the further spread of such manners is to avoid the contact with Asiatics, not merely in the colonies but in Asia or any other part of the globe, until they are placed on an equal footing and able
THE BRITAINS 127
to hold their own. Should no such step be taken, good manners and high breeding will become as rare in Britain as in the Colonies and in the United States of America, towards all classes and races, dark or fair. Already the Colonial habit of addressing a stranger as " mister " has supplanted the old-world polite epithet of " sir." It is not yet too late for the enfranchised masses of Europe to avoid the poisonous leaven that Colonial example has introduced. Cultured and humane persons in all classes have not yet suc- cumbed to these demoralizing influences, but signs are not wanting that such influences, if continued much longer, may, like incessant dripping of water on the hardest stone or continuous ham- mering on the firmest substance, have the usual effect of bending or breaking the most upright and Christian disposition. The difference be- tween the Old and the New World, between Europe and its oversea products of mixed races, was recently exemplified at the annual Reception of a well-known London club where a negro lady and gentleman were invited. An American guest remonstrated with the secretary for per- mitting the presence of negroes, " whom we would not admit to our social functions." The secre- tary coolly replied, " We in Europe make no such distinction." The appearance of an in- creasing number of Africans in the streets of
128 ORIENT AND OCCIDENT
the metropolis seems from writings in the Press to be having a disturbing effect upon the soft brain of a certain type of Londoners.
It is difhcult to understand why the Colonials who have been granted self-government have taken such a dislike to Asiatics. Asiatics never thought of thrusting themselves on Europe or on the Colonies. Europe encouraged them to shake off their exclusiveness, and the Colonies — notably Natal, the most shameless offender of all— sought them as labourers ; then, having got what they could out of them, they wanted to send them away. They are quite justified in trying to do without Asiatics, but is it necessary or politic to make enemies of them — and of their countrymen— by insults and inhuman treatment? The Colonials may stand to the Asiatics in the position of peers to the humble classes in Europe, or of the higher castes to the " pariahs " in India. They may not intermarry or take food or have social inter- course with the Asiatics ; but why deny them political justice, when in aristocratic Britain men and women scarcely able to read and write or to understand what they read have been given the vote, and scions of noble families and men with the bluest blood "condescend" to sit, discuss, and yote on equal terms with Labour Members in the House of Commons? Or is it because, unable to maintain distinction of blood, blue or
THE BRITAINS 129
yellow, and debarred from claiming the distinc- tion of being European, they have invented a new distinction based on the " colour " or " colourlessness " of skin as their instrument for perpetuating human animosities and miseries? Besides, there are among Asiatics persons quite as " white " as Colonials, and in such cases the continental bar and not the colour bar is invoked for the assertion of privilege. It may be desirable to discourage illiteracy and ignorance, and the qualification may be made as strict and as high as practicable, but to disfranchise men of educa- tion— some of whom are certainly not less educated and less civilized than many Colonials —simply because they are of Asiatic origin, or because their skin has a darker shade, is a curious procedure on the part of men that still profess the religion promulgated by an Asiatic.
Still more curious is the statesmanship that connives at this policy of insults and pinpricks and sows the seeds of disruption within the Empire. It is fit that a Tory administration should sanction the introduction of inequality in legal privilege, which is the principle of Toryism, because it would like to have precedent for rein- troduction of inequality into Britain ; but it is strange that Liberals should be forced to sanction such policy. It is somewhat odd to speak of
10
130 ORIENT AND OCCIDENT
peace and of Empire while enmity and in- iiumanity
"under the smile of safety wound the State."
Japan by a slaughter of a hundred thousand of her white-skinned enemies has put a stop to the use by the European Press of the insulting epithet of " yellow man," and she has made her- self strong enough to be " granted " an alliance, as the Tory Foreign Under-Secretary expressed it in the House, with the British Empire. The " grant " was before she proved her prowess against Russia. But Japan has not yet been able to secure fair treatment for the complexion of her sons in the Colonies, and will probably not succeed in doing so until circumstances enable her to teach the Colonials a lesson in good man- ners. It would be well for the British Empire if the Colonials would suggest to his Majesty's Indian subjects what they can do to merit some of the fair treatment which British aristocrats have vouchsafed to the Colonials, in order that all who own allegiance to the British Crown may stand shoulder to shoulder in defence of the best interests of the Empire and of mankind. It is doubtless clever statesmanship to try to conciliate the Colonies, but it is a strange fatalism which denies to India anything like the same liberality,
THE BRITAINS 131
and which prevents her rulers from being anxious to raise in the estimation of the world the country they administer.
It is said that the Colonials are " kith and kin." Intermarriage, which is the sign of kinship, does not appear to be common between the better classes in Britain and the Colonials. As regards kinship by race, the Aryans of India may claim to be kin, although on one side
" Minds swayed by eyes are full of turpitude " ;
and on the other the proud and self-complacent castes would hardly like to admit kinship with the foreigner, however " bleached by northern blasts " his skin may be, or whatever political power he may exercise. Such kinship is irrefutably proved by similarity of physical features and supported by linguistic relationship. European nations will be tumbling over one another to claim kinship if India, like Japan, can again place herself in the front rank of mankind.
" One touch of nature makes the whole world kin " ;
and kinship at any rate may with advantage, like nationality, be extended to all persons that own allegiance to the same Sovereign, unless a new doctrine of " imperialist " Christianity be promul- gated, declaring the different branches of the
132 ORIENT AND OCCIDENT
human family to be the creation of rival Creators, in which case, as with rival nations, it should be permissible to the creation of one Creator to try to injure or annihilate a rival. There is shrewd- ness in the desire to extend kinship only to those from whom favour is expected or danger is apprehended.
Partiality on the part of authority, not being in accordance with the old idea of British states- manship, is called by expatriated Europeans " statesmanship of the British race." British statesmanship without distinction of party is well known to be guided by the highest principles of justice and fair play (note the statesmanship of Sir Stafford Northcote, the first Earl of Iddes- leigh ), and of freedom from any bonds that retard the development of human faculties. The triumph of these principles has been witnessed in the education and enfranchisement of the humbler classes in Britain, in the dissipation of religious intolerance, and in the grant of self- government to the Colonies. British statesman- ship has always endeavoured to act up to the liberal traditions that " God never made one nation good enough to rule another," and that " good government cannot be secured without self-government." It recognizes that it is not enough to desire power over fellow-creatures without deserving it by their admiration, and
THE BRITAINS 133
that the administration of justice has to inspire confidence in its impartiality. It knows that among nations, as among individuals, it is im- possible for one to understand another if no fellow-feeling, sympathy, or affection subsists. British statesmanship is inspired by the tra- ditional aspiration to unify the Empire by the bonds of affection and common interest in its welfare : it is only recently that it has showed hesitation at the loud barking of reaction and the consequent response of weak-kneed Britons in every party ; but, even in times of timidity and hesitation, it does not renounce its concern for all classes of the people. Statesmanship of the " British race," on the other hand, is the product of its connection with other races in the Colonies and in India ; it lacks the good breeding and manners of true Britons, insults the people it is exercised upon without having the courage to exterminate them, displays its shrewdness only by fomenting discord between classes, creeds, and races forming the Empire, and, failing other methods, condemns every reform as undermining its prestige. Statesmanship of the " British race " will never care to understand India or Asia, because the faculty or feeling that helps to under- stand and sharpens reason does not exist in that race. Failing other qualifications, the new states- manship bases its claim to consideration and
134 ORIENT AND OCCIDENT
power on the possession of a particular skin colour or want of colour. It is unable to com- prehend the teaching of history that dominion and authority are not secured by skin, but by display of faculties that evoke reverence. In the view of this statesmanship, a fair skin, although reared in the despotic atmosphere of continental governments, is better qualified to be of the '' British race " than Indians born British subjects and bred in the moral atmosphere of Britain, merely because these have a shade in complexion. The action of the Colonials in showing their contempt and want of consideration for his Majesty's dark-skinned subjects, although it may stand in the way of the solidarity of the Empire, would be comparatively harmless if the effects of such action were confined to the Colonies themselves. Their example, however, spreads abroad, and operates most injuriously among the Europeans that reside in India, who, although debarred from privileges (except when they com- mit crime), expect the same sort of preferential treatment from the authorities and assert their claim to treat their Asiatic fellow -subjects with brutal contempt. The example does not even remain confined to India, although the most harm is doubtless done there : it is infecting all classes in Britain, who naturally feel hesitation to side with people that submit tamely to such treatment.
THE BRITAINS 135
From the moment, however, that such action and policy receive the sanction or connivance of the rulers of the Empire at its heart, and his Majesty's Ministers, while indulging in half-hearted expres- sions of sympathy with the sufferers, express their inability to interfere with the self-governing Colonies or to permit retaliation against Colonials in the directly governed dominions, a racial struggle is initiated which can end only with the exclusion of one or the other of the contending factions from the Empire, and which is bound to introduce other conditions detrimental to its stability.
The excuse put forward by some bigots, that Asiatics are not Christians, is scarcely borne out by the treatment meted out to Asiatic Christians, who fare no better than their non-Christian brethren. It may be true that the manners and habits of the mass of Asiatics are somewhat different from the better class of Europeans, but they are not more different than are the manners and habits of the classes out of which the Colonials spring from those of " gentle " folk in Europe, between whom there is little in common except the skin complexion. Besides, to contend that no Asiatic can be equal in manners to any European is not only rebellion against the reign of Jesus Christ : it would be no more just than it was for the upper classes in Europe to deny to
136 ORIENT AND OCCIDENT
any European of the humbler classes equality with their order. However manners may differ, and however desirable it may be to avoid each other's shadow, nothing is gained by nursing a feeling of animosity. The Colonial claim is nothing but an arrogant assertion of superiority of a petted and pampered portion of the Empire, and of their ability to dictate to its rulers. The attitude of British statesmen is incomprehensible, since there is nothing to show that in the hour of need the Colonials will be more helpful to the Empire than Indians, or that they will claim no return for any service they may render to their Sovereign. In any case, if this civil strife is permitted to continue within the Empire, or to grow as it has been doing for some years, it is vain to expect peace and prosperity under the existing political conditions. Asiatics, if not permitted to give blow for blow, which alone will bring the uncultured Colonial to reason, will be driven to seek other means of rousing his conscience and of advancing the happiness of mankind. The British Empire or Dominions or Possessions— by whatever name it may please people to caJl the British territories in Asia— cannot be safe under present conditions. Until the people of India are fully trusted, and bold statesmanship removes all barriers from their paths of service to their Sovereign and country, the British
THE BRITAINS 137
dominions will owe a good deal of their security to foreign alliances or to the goodwill of foreign nations. Political arrangements are shifting from day to day, and any policy which drives Japan from the British alliance, or alienates Russia, can hardly be conducive to the safety of the British Empire. If the policy of the Colonies towards Asiatics is not speedily changed, the day will arrive when Britain will have to choose between her Colonial independencies and her Asiatic dependency. The British alliance at a critical period has been of considerable service to Japan, and proverbial Asiatic gratitude will induce Japan to be always on the side of Britain if British statesmanship does not yield to Colonial prejudices so as to show that they consider the interests of Colonial tradesmen greater than the honour and self-respect of the Japanese nation and the safety of the Empire. The Colonies occupy the most favoured position imaginable. They have in their legislation or administration no fear of the veto of the Peers. They enjoy the protection of Britain against foreign invasion without adequate contribution to its cost. They tax British products as much as suits their pur- pose of protecting native industries. They can exclude even Britons from their soil on the plea of their being " undesirable aliens." In spite of cloudy and questionable antecedents, they have
138 ORIENT AND OCCIDENT
become so respectable as to ask Europe to send them immigrants from " among the best " and " of the right sort," not being loyal enough to their ancestry to doubt any European to be other- wise. That is not all. The human mind is so constituted that the more it gets the more it asks. Some of the Colonies, like persons in rail- way and domestic service objecting to the name " servant " as degrading, refuse to be called " a British Colony," and claim the right to make commercial treaties with foreign States without the intervention of the Central Authority, and to control the Foreign and Defensive policy of the Empire. Their only remaining step is to pro- claim independence of Britain, or to declare Britain to be subordinate to them, as soon as they find that the security of her Empire in any way depends upon the help of the dominions beyond the sea.
If the Colonies are sincere in the wish they at times express to be partners in the trials of Britain, they should place themselves, as India is placed, under the complete control of the Home Government in military and naval as in foreign affairs. The defensive and offensive strength of the Empire should be so organized as the British Cabinet may direct, and on a footing of strict co-ordination, for it can be effective only if all the forces are subordinate to the supreme military
THE BRITAINS 139
and naval authority of the Empire— the Army Council or the Defence Committee of the Cabinet. A complete and uniform plan of naval and mili- tary inter-connection is absolutely essential for the defence and welfare of his Majesty's dominions all over the world. Until this is done, professions of friendship and promises of help by com- munities that cannot help themselves will not contribute to the safety of